That story about the rose tea and jelly comparisons is great, that kind of local variety knowledge just disappears. Rugosa hips really are something else for making syrup, the flavour is much more complex than the bland dried ones you get in shops. I have a couple of planted rugosas and they produce well enough but nowhere near the size of wild coastal ones, must be something about the conditions.
grab one for me also if you dont mind. ![]()
We use wild roses for tea and jelly here. Carolina and Swamp are the most utilized locally. Virgina and Multiflora less. Have not seen wild Rugosa here yet.
About 15 years ago i started making wine, i was making wine from everything that was possible.
I came across a big patch of wild/feral roses along a nature trail full of hips. I collected a bag full and started up a 1 gallon batch of wine. It smelled soo good as it was fermenting, when it was finished and i was ready to bottle it up, it still smelled nice, but had lost some of itās wonderful fragrance. I couldnāt resist, even though it wasnāt aged I wanted to try a glass. It was the worst wine that I had ever tasted.
I didnāt bother bottling it, poured it out. Took forever to get that nasty taste out of my mouth.
Interesting, the largest I have seen are on the hill above the South Shore beach in Milwaukee⦠like bright red crab apples. Iāll take a look when I walk the dog.
As others have mentioned, rugosa roses are excellent for hips. My favorite is āScabrosa.ā I live in southeast Michigan, zone 6a. It gets through the winter with ease. It does spread, here. Not super aggressive, but it does spread from the root.
Hereās its ID: 'Scabrosa' Rose
Make a wild tea with the flower petals. Like drinking liquid sunshine. I have had jelly made from petals as well.
its probably the asian beach rose, which is a type of rugosa rose. the hips are the size of a crab apple. even bigger than some.
My own experience with Rosa rugosa was unpleasant, to say the least. It was a suckering, spreading, sprawling, thorny monster that barely gave me a handful of lackluster hips in 10 years! I will Never be planting it again!
I have heard apple roses are superior, but never tried them.
About mid-summer I bought Dartās Dash and Raspberry Rugostar (forget from whom, but the price was right) and planted them in the worst of the heat. They both established roots and pushed a small side cane. They are just beginning to change leaf color for fall and the buds for next year are fat and bright red. I expect next season to be able to tell you all how the hips work out, but am pretty confident this was a good move.
@Ariel I use dried rose hips and fresh yarrow leaf instead of hops in ale every other year. They preserve it well and impart an orange flavor to the ale. I do this because yarrow also imparts a substance that gives you a boost for a few hours, good to have with dinner when I sing in rehearsal or concert after an already full day.
My hope is to learn if Rugosa hips offer a similar flavor profile. Am rather confident it will be close enough, as the cold rosehip dessert soup I enjoyed in Sweden had that.
Also Ariel: one must cut open each hip and scrape out the seeds before use, which is why larger hips are valued. There is a wild rose out this way with hips a quarter inch across. I gathered them and went thru the procedure, which was tedious in the extreme. And that flavor was disappointing.
Unfortunately, I donāt think they are hardy in zone 4; they werenāt in my zone 5 garden.
@NuttingBumpus Thatās really interesting about the yarrow leavesāI didnāt know that!
We also have wild roses around here (I think Rosa multiflora) that have tiny little hips. They certainly donāt look worth the effort! Occasionally Iāll get one on my David Austin or Kordes roses but somehow Iām guessing they probably donāt have the best flavor but who knows!
Rosa canina (canida?) - dog rose - gets some love in the literature, but it looked to be a climber or spreader & more than I had room to offer, so I went with Rugosa. Will report when results come in.
Ariel: yarrow grows wild around here. I gather the leaves until I get 48 inches of it to put, muddled (mashed in a stone mortar and pestle), & put in a five gallon batch of ale along with an ounce or two of dried rose hips. They work together nicely. This ale gets started with much less time than is required using hops, as the important bits from hops must be boiled an hour before it gets in solution.
Caution: donāt double the amount of yarrow. I tried it and found my heart hammering through the night, with very little sleep. The amount I use preserves ale and gives a moderate boost while allowing me to sleep at a normal time.
Yarrow has some darker properties. Thujune found in Yarrow can lead to or induce miscarriage.
Years ago I saw Rosa pomifera. Giant hips! Not sure if they are tasty. Any rose hip I ever tried left me wondering why anyone would want to eat them. Did not try them in tea however.
Rosa rubrifolia also had large hips but not quite as large as Rosa pomifera.
Sounds like a cool ale. Curious where you found or how you came up with the recipe. Iāve tried some really amazing Gruit ales and some really horrible ones. The rose hip/yarrow combo seems better than most of the recipes Iāve seen.
@NuttingBumpus I assume yarrow could be used as a tea or something as well? I seem to be pretty sensitive to caffeine so I wonder how Iād respond to yarrow.
@dannytoro1 Very good to know, especially considering that Iām pregnant! Iād definitely want to do my research, pregnant or not.
Considering the coumarin content (believe that is the correct term) in yarrow, I wonder how strong it must be to trigger abortion and am inclined to think it would be an uncomfortable dose to the rest of your system before reaching that threshold. On the other hand, I would caution your use of it at all until the baby is shown to the world.
After that, ale was considered good for mother and nursing babe for thousands of years, and that meant ales without hops for most of history. Again, take it slowly.
High Country Roses offers Rosa pomifera earlier in the season - out of stock this late in the year - for $28. Itās a big bush in ideal conditions: 6-8 feet tall by 6 feet wide. Single petal, single bloom, apple-like hips (hence the binomial).
I think this is the outfit from which I obtained Dartās Dash and Raspberry Rugostar.
My elderly neighbor planted the rose tree with thousands of thorns and the Huge rose hips that ripen to mush that i have learned to get them and make teas and dry . i have tons of seeds . if any one is interested. not sure what rose it is but i can get photos of the hips and thorns . we once used it as a joke making a wreath . but stopped when we couldnt stop our fingers from bleeding due to all the thorns.