I think the “gourmet” variety is the one that isn’t produced in huge quantities in your neighborhood. :). Once I visited a farmer’s market in LA. There were “Fuyu” persimmons (mostly still green) for sale by the thousands. it’s hard to think of Fuyu as gourmet after that. On the other hand I’ve seen adds for individual, gift-wrapped, ripe Taishu fruits in Japan for >$20.
You seem to be saying that warm sunny days are more frequent (“high temp curve is smoother”) in the PNW, which helps remove astringency there. The problem is that Ram harvests astringent PCNAs in the PNW. My weather in RI is more erratic (and sometimes rainy in summer) yet my IKKJs, Taishus, and Izus have no astringency.
I had a couple that recently came back from a visit to Japan and they were raving about persimmons. They were really excited to try my persimmons since they had had such a positive experience.
I had them try H118 and a few hybrids. They were both so impressed by these and even said these were far better than the ones they had in Japan.
The first Izu I purchased ended up being a PCA kaki that resembles Hachiya. So I had full confidence that it wasn’t really Izu. My replacement Izu is a PCNA, so it may well be Izu, but I can’t distinguish it from my purported Wasu Fuyu or Maekawa Jiro from the same nursery. They all ripen at about the same time, and the fruit seems identical. That makes me wonder how confident any of us can be that what we’ve purchased from commercial nurseries or received in trades is truly Izu, Fuyu, Jiro, or other related PCNA varieties when the differences between them are relatively subtle. There does seem to be a good deal of confusion around kaki persimmons, even among generally reputable and reliable nurseries. I suspect that our different experiences with growing what are allegedly the same varieties may be a result of mislabeling as much as climate, shade, moisture, etc…
Exactly, that’s what I was trying to say - if the differences are too subtle then it makes it hard for any of us to distinguish a mis-labeled tree from the real thing, and we may not be comparing the same varieties at all, even if we sourced them from the same nursery.
The main innovation of the Japanese breeding program seems to have been greater dispersion of ripening times, with the development of early ripeners such as Soshu and Izu. This was complete serendipity. It wasn’t a goal of the program and it came as a surprise. Even now I think it’s unclear why crossing mid/late-season ripeners should lead to an offspring that is early ripening.
Fuyu and Jiro are preety different.
first is the flowering and mature time.
jiro flower 2~3 week early then fuyu and harvest time is about 3 week early.
second is the shape of fruit.
jiro has crack along the vertical which i can only discribe it has “buttcrack” like.
this charastic is some time weaker but usually obvious.shape more rectangular.
fuyu rarly has this buttcrack and are more round.
branching habit is also a little different. fuyo has more strong straight water sprout
jiro has more twig and small branch.
they are more difference these are just the obvious one.
but Maekawa Jiro and Jiro (the origianl) i can;t tell the different.
it suposs to ripe early then jiro.
very subtle indeed. i literally need a spread sheet to tell the different.
Unlike true taxonomy, cultivars do not have an absolutely correct standard such as a holotype for reference when there is uncertainty in their definition.
However, the Japanese Ministry of Agriculture has made significant efforts to collect and document the major characteristic of many cultivars, common varieties such as Fuyu, Jiro, and Saoshū can be referenced against these records.
As for my American friends your beloved DV hybrids —good luck.
Thank you for describing these differences between Fuyu and Jiro types of PCNA persimmons. I didn’t intend to imply that there aren’t any noticeable differences, and I can distinguish between the typical round Fuyu and slightly lobed Jiro types among those PCNA persimmons I grow. My concern is that many nurseries selling these trees in the US mislabel them. For example, my Izu, Wase Fuyu and Maekawa Jiro have identical round fruit that ripens at the same time. That makes it hard for us to trust the observations of backyard growers with only a few trees. Would they really know if what they purchased as Jiro is actually a Fuyu, or vice versa? As long as the fruit is non-astringent, they probably will just accept what the nursery tells them unless they grow many different varieties of PCNA and have reason to be suspicious about mislabeled trees like I am.