Giant Chestnuts

For the hardiest (and therefore Chinese-based) chestnuts as an experiment:

Dubuque, Iowa had lows of -16 F the last 3 years in a row. You could try contacting Red Fern Farm in Iowa or Perfect Circle Farm in New Hampshire and try to grow seedlings or start from seed. I am a newbie but I saw your question hadn’t been answered. In my notes based on reading only but not experience, I had Chinese chestnut names written out: Sleeping Giant, Luvall’s Monster, Eaton, Qing, Mossbarger, Large Badger, Giant Badger, Badgerqing, Gellatly Sweet. Dunstan is another choice.

I’ve heard from several farms in Zone 4 Wisconsin, but none were in the production stage. One showed pictures that they were growing. They started from seed or seedlings, often Dustan seedlings.

If anyone is reading in warmer Zone 4b, I heard from someone closer to Lake Superior whose Japanese-European chestnuts were at least surviving winter.

2 Likes

i have 2 chinese surviving 4 winters so far and slowly growing. they havent grown much but nothing in that orchard really is other than hazels and my sole b. locust. i need to test the soil up there. i suspect its very acidic. i have 5 dunstans planted from seed in ground in apr. that grew about 6in. the dunstans in pots grew 2ft. i need to get them in ground asap.

Have your grafted trees been doing well?

In Minneapolis as a beginner gardener I have not had good luck with grafted chestnuts so far. But I didn’t set the soil pH correctly until this year. And I didn’t learn to prune the layered clone to one single branch until exactly yesterday. I seal pruning cuts with toilet ring wax to survive winter. My Colossal seedling is looking okay and starting to grow in it’s 3rd summer. The layered Okei clone survived 2 winters with a -22 F low temperature, but one Michigan website says Okei fails as a pollinator in northern climates, so I plan to discard mine after I see how it handles pruning to coax it back to acting like a tree instead of a branch.

I’m hoping to buy several Japanese-European seedlings next year (I already dug holes for them), while waiting a year on grafted and layered. I have grafted persimmons as my experimental plants in the meantime.

Ooh okay interesting. I am in a very similar climate to you. That’s promising to hear they are surviving -22 F temperatures!

I have 10 different Euro/Jap grafted cultivars that I’m hoping will survive the winters in my area: Central Wisconsin

Bouche De Betizac
Colossal
Bisalta No.3
Sleeping Giant
Tsukuba
Tanzawa
Marigoule
Marsol
Layeroka
Precoce Migoule

I also have seedlings of Qing, Gideon, Eaton, and Perry.

Everything is looking good so far, but we’ll see what this winter brings.

For zone 4b I will try seedlings of: Precoce Migoule, Marsol, Marigoule, Bisalta #3, Belle Epine. That’s my expected harvest order if cloned. Maybe Layeroka. Have Colossal.

I do wonder if these types of Euro/Jap seedlings will produce as good quality of nuts as their parentage.

I’ve heard that most Chinese seedlings produce good offspring, but Euro/Jap types are considerably more variable.

Have you tried any Chinese varieties?

I’ve been to Chinese markets in California and been disappointed by the flavor of imported Chinese chestnuts compared to the Japanese-European nuts I order as “Tree Seeds” from Burnt Ridge Nursery.

2 Likes

when i was stationed in s. korea, there was a bunch of chinese chestnuts there at the park. i tried eating one. i found it bitter but once the burs fell the koreans that worked on the base scoffed them up so i guess they had a way to prepare them properly?

I think certain chestnuts benefit from being cooked to prevent that bitterness or to subdue the tannins.

See 2nd paragraph of this post: