Orchard Birds

The wife has a fellow gooser trying to sell her those fancy Eastern European Sevastopol Geese. $75 each is a stellar price. But we would have to buy the entire flock…I am not made of that kind of money. There are over 30 of them!

Not to mention a new enclosure would have to be built.

1 Like

Anyone have any theories on why my American Holly berries are rarely consumed by birds? They were planted about 20 years ago (based on Google Maps history) by the previous owners and they are always heavily loaded. The fruit just sits on the trees until eventually they drop and are replaced with the current fruit set. I put a few bird feeders on the branches in the hopes that it entices them but they are the most popular trees for the smaller birds already, they just ignore the berries. They have no issues eating the berries I can eat though.

you sure its an american and if iti s, is it native there

this is the bonap range for Ilex opaca which what people normally call american holly, so most of “Central” PA is out of the range though not crazy out of the range

2 Likes

Yeah it’s definitely American Holly (unless there’s some very similar look alike) and that makes sense, not at all far from the native range like you said. I never got to actually talk to the owner when I bought the place but based on the trees being in a weird spot in the yard but conveniently visible from the bedroom, I assume their goal was bird watching. Maybe the 2 bird pictures hung on that wall primed me for that conclusion haha.

Random pictures of one of the trees on July 30th:

im not a fan of those. they are like the silkies of geese. not a practical choice.

1 Like

Those berries are not on the top of most birds lists.. more like survival when all other options are gone. So there is more likely much preferred food sources nearby. It takes several freezes and thaws to make the berries sweet… by that time birds have found other food sources like locals feeding them etc. I guess a good analogy would be that you havent eaten in a week.. your options are unripe green persimmons or keep moving until you see that someone has left out some scraps.

Bird seed is sold by the pallets in most of my local box stores and feed stores.. they obviously sell alot of it. I buy lots of feed myself.

So your holly is competing with food that they prefer..

Your holly is obsolete in your area as a food source… or you have a severe decline in birds.

2 Likes

This niche is occupied by winter berry in my area. The bushes are absolutely loaded this year and also make great decorations for the holidays. The birds won’t touch them until everything else in the landscape is exhausted and asleep for the year.

2 Likes

We watch the Sevastopols regularly sell for $250 a bird in the Florida Exotic Auction. They are the ultimate goose for McMansion ponds…lol

Other fine orchard/farm bug patrol birds. Mixed Game/Bantams. Very smart, cagey at avoiding predators. And genocidal bug hunters.

I’d would say Guineas too. But that is an acquired{you need to be deaf} taste.

2 Likes

I agree, I think they just don’t need the fruit and it’s low preference. No shortage of birds here but one benefit the holly trees provide is when the birds perch on the branches and drop more black raspberry seeds, among many other things. I moved a few of those seedlings into a managed row just to see what happens and what kind of quality the plant lottery will give me.

If I personally planted something for the birds, Holly wouldn’t be my first choice but since so many critters use the trees, I let them remain. I only plant trees with edible crops here because of my limited space otherwise.

1 Like

I was thinking of making wreaths with my Holly branches since nothing uses the berries and they look like a perfect holiday decoration.

3 Likes

If it is in your budget and desire to attract and feed birds this winter as they migrate in and out.. there are plenty of options just about everywhere.

If you like to recycle there are endless options..

I put out over 1000 lbs of black oil sunflower seed per year. I have yet to see a fat bird.

Right or wrong? I am not sure but i enjoy it.

2 Likes

And I’ll suggest please consider a predator guard on nest box poles. Here I use a very stout maybe 3 foot wide cone. Otherwise bluebirds are sitting ducks for raccoons, black snake.

3 Likes

Don’t know why birds don’t like them. In the late winter, when there isn’t much for them to eat I see robins eating them.

1 Like

Another thing with nest boxes the size is pretty specific to different birds. And please watch for invasive house sparrows. They will sometimes kill native bluebirds and take over their nest.

Birdhouse gourds are fun to grow. Need to start them early (unless one has a long season) as they take a long time to mature

This house wren took up residency in one this past spring, though there were no chicks. My understanding is they have decoy nests.

Free pest control.

2 Likes

i only feed the birds through the winter. i want them actively hunting bugs and stuff in the yard and not become freeloaders all summer. :wink: i also dont want to encourage squirrels and mice to come for the droppings either esp. voles.

4 Likes

Cornell keeps their feeders full year round.. and has a live streaming of it. (best enjoyed in the morning and afternoon EST).

I think its easy to see looking around most everywhere that lots of habitat has been lost to civilization as well as folks that mow or whatever they do in open areas that no longer carry the seeds that they once ate.

I know that i have many many hundreds of birds in my area whereas i can see none or very very few anywhere else in my community.

As far as bugs and stuff.. i remember decades ago that folks had ‘bras’ on their cars and ‘bug shields’ and it was handy to carry bug remover as well as have bug remover windshield washer fluid.

My car at the time had its front bumper and hood damaged by the bugs.. the paint was beaten off by hitting so many bugs.

However now.. There are no ‘bugs and stuff’ issues anymore…at least that i can see here.

As far as voles go.. they eat birdseed year round..maybe more so in the winter.

Which coming full circle.. feeding birds in feeders also attracts birds of prey.. And i want more predator birds to hunt voles as well.. I have watched hawks and owls kill both voles and songbirds.

Not saying any of this to argue right or wrong.. but i see more birds via feeding year round and more birds of prey as well.. than most anywhere else i visit or see locally.

3 Likes

When I first moved in, I put up sunflower seed, nyjer seed and suet feeders.

I got a lot of birds that I hadn’t seen as much of before. Wrens, woodpeckers, chickadees, nuthatches, titmice, finches and new world sparrows

Over time I stopped feeding nyjer, because it was a bit of a hassle, and sunflower because it attracted all the rodents. I still feed suet but only in the winter. I still see the same assortment of birds in my backyard though it is no longer just a bare lawn. With all the different plants there are more bugs and the bugs brings the birds (plus a lot of the birds will eat the spent flowers and seeds)

3 Likes

my bird population here has exploded since all my plantings have matured in the last 2-3 yrs. without me feeding them. they obviously are finding plenty if theyre all over my yard. i see birds ive never seen before and they all hang out together hunting/ foraging in my plantings.. i had a pair of bluebirds show up and stay all summer. never seen those around here before now. they must have had a nest nearby. if i sit quietly in the morning or evening in the yard , i have dozens of species flittering by. they will sometimes surround me, checking me out. esp. the chickadees. theyre curious lil’ buggers. saw my 1st pair ever here of canadian jays last year. they are usually a big woods species. 5 yrs ago i had a pair of piliated woodpeckers nest in a dead poplar at the back of the property. very rare to see them nowadays due to habitat loss. they hatched 3 chicks. like you, i dont see alot of birds in other places but im doing something right if they are hanging out all day in the numbers i see regularly. in winter i just open my livingroom window and throw the seed right on the snow. after the 1st day, they come in droves. squirrels cant get to it as the snows too deep to support them. voles are under the snow so they dont access it either. i only throw out several scoops a day and it gets scarfed up in short order.

3 Likes

I like birds but they have never been a plus in my orchards. No way not even close. I have lived in areas with a minimum of pests. But if birds are so helpful why are most people spraying every time they turn around. For certain pests in certain situations, yes they are some help. The last apricots I had ripening outside went 99% to the birds. Grapes the same way. Apples roughly 50% loss. That was one of many things I liked about my greenhouse. Zero bird damage. And no pests beyond spider mites. Birds don’t cure that issue either.

4 Likes

My take on things from my Biology passion-

Spraying by humans removes most insects on fruit.

Fruit is a method of reproduction for fruiting things.. so it attracts things to consume the fruit and spread the seed.

The insects evolved to eat the fruits.. the birds evolved to eat the insects that eat the fruit.

As noted before birds have evolved to lure insects by damaging fruit..

The birds have a life cycle that revolves around eating insects.

We do not discuss the negative impacts of spraying on the ecosystem.. only the positive aspects of having fruit free of insect and bird damage.

I am not sure many commercial crops of anything with fruits or grains(which is fruit of the crop plant) is safe from insects or birds.. without pesticides.

If you want consistant blemish free fruits or garden fruits or fruits of grains.. i think you probably must spray or apply chemicals.

I think we all remember the movies with the crop dusting planes..

Probably everything that i have eaten in my life has been sprayed.

The facts seem that there is an insect apocalypse(severe collapse of insects). The facts seem that there is also a massive bird decline..

Does it matter? Not really as we have figured out how to transport bees to places that bees cannot live due to pesticides. As a rule we do not care about the grain crops that feed the animals that people eat… so those are bombarded with insecticides where nothing can live.. nor does it matter because that is being fed to animals not humans.

It doesnt matter what is sprayed on club fruits.. as long as its blemish free. There are no warning labels nor information that i can see on any fruit. I am not sure that it matters in other countries what they spray as long as people buy the fruit here.

Long story short.. Stephan said better than i can.. if you want blemish free fruits and all of your crop.. get rid of the birds and insects. You cant have both.

We have imported fruiting things from all over the world as well as their pests from all over the world. Not all birds or predator insects are adapted to the adaptions of those insects.. We have created an imbalance. We have also created an imbalance of beneficials as well as imbalances of native fruits, seeds, habitats, climate etc etc etc etc.

I love nature.. i love my walkabouts. I love watching wasps eating aphids as well as birds destroying tent worms.. spider webs in the branches…lizards lying in wait. Birds feeding their young.. i love the bumblebees and mason bees as well as my wild honeybees having infinite forage.

If i spray every time i turn around.. that goes away.

So i say its a choice. Its your land, your time your desire. But i do think you have to make a choice when it comes to growing. You have to be a robber baron and monopolize your fruiting things.. or you become a ‘hippy gardener’ who focuses harmony with nature, and a rejection of industrialized farming.

Personally i think that fruiting things, insects and birds were here long long before my peoples were. I think that most of the things that each of them ate are gone.. and we have replaced with things that are for us not them. Yet we still want them around sort of..sometimes when it pleases us.

I am not sure how a bird and insect apocalypse would work.. but i do think that it would enable folks to grow fruit without worry other than pollination which the Chinese etc are now having to do by hand. I think they have also removed the birds and insects as well mostly.