Our Apple Experiences

I would like to start a thread where contributors can provide very detailed descriptions of the apples they grow, and every travail that is a part of the growing experience. There is much information on this forum already, but with the exception of Scott’s observations, things are scattered or relevant details are lacking.

The following details should be included

  1. State and county
  2. Altitude
  3. Average rainfall
  4. Age of tree or years of experience with tree(s)
  5. Tree rootstock
  6. Name of nursery

Williams Favorite

1000’ Alt
49" annual rainfall
Surry County, NC

I grew this apple for about 15 years. It was purchased from Century Farms.

This tree has very thick twigs that never seem to narrow more than the width of a pencil. The leaves are very large and robust.

It’s a tip bearer. It blooms over a long period of time and tends to spit out pesky dud blossoms when insecticide applications need to take place.

The tree is medium vigor and very prone to fire blight at my location. It does see some Glomerella on the leaves only.

The fruit ripens the first half of July.

The fruit are absolutely stunning in appearance and is probably among the top 5 apples in overall appearance. The fruit are medium large in size. They are generally crimson red, and are conical and are oblong. The fruit is white sometimes with red staining near the skin. The flesh density is fairly low, but not spongy. The fruit normally drops the day they’re ripe and they will keep about a week. The flavor is tart, not sour, and with a nice burn. They can be cooked but are require a lot of sweetener. The potency of the tartness does not fade when cooked.

Summer Banana

I inherited two full size Summer Banana apples on their own roots and also rooted one on its own roots at my MIL’s family farm @ 1310’ Alt in Surry county. I’ve been involved with this variety since 1995.

This tree grows many limbs and twigs and is a tip bearer. The flower buds and blossoms are much smaller than most apples, even smaller than the Golden D but are very plentiful. The fruit size is medium or slightly below. It blooms the same time as the Stayman and Winesap and may be partially self-fertile. I suspect it’s the offspring of the Golden Delicious.

It wants to grow branches at narrow angles and requires extensive pruning if growing a larger tree. That’s why I’ve downsized to G41.

It is prone to CAR, Glomerella, and likely apple blotch which is more of a post harvest foliage issue. It does see some fire blight during worst years.

The fruit is prone to predation due to ripening time and must be sprayed for apple maggot.
The flavor is very similar to a Golden Delicious without the sweet white wine rub.

The Banana flavor people speak of is actually the peel. The Summer Banana apple peel flavor is similar to the flavor of banana peel. The flesh is cream colored and is semi fibrous, but not quite as bad as the Willams Pride when cooked. It’s a great eating out of hand apple and makes decent pies as well. They can be cooked, but I don’t like the texture although the flavor is quite pleasant.

Ripening is Aug 1-15. They do not keep.

Yellow Delicious

This tree was purchased from Willis Orchards in 2009 at my MIL’s behest. It was planted on the old family farm in Surry Cnty NC. It blew down in the Spring of 2025. It was on a M111 rootstock.

This tree was largely trouble free. It did some similar growth habits of the Golden D, but the Yellow D is far more disease resistant. Far less fire blight, much less rots. While the flavor of this apple isn’t terribly inspiring and hard to describe. Perhaps a mild sweet apple with a musty mango wash. The fruit were shaped well and never turned yellow unless they were nearly rotting.

When I cut two old Summer B apples down back around 2020, the tree stopped producing apples since the only companion tree at that point was a Winesap. This suggests the Yellow D is not self fertile like the Golden D is.

I will be adding more trees to this post. Feel free to reply with your deets.

4 Likes

This seems like a great idea for a topic to me. Helpful for decision making!

2 Likes

Yellow D is supposed to be Golden D, just renamed.

2 Likes

Back around 2009-2020, it’s my understanding that Willis grafted their own trees. During that period, there were no order errors for anything I ordered which included berries, apricot, plum, peach, apples.

The fruit of the Yellow D I grew is identical to the Yellow Ds at the store. Any assertion that this tree was not a Yellow D isn’t valid from my perspective. Seedling, sport mutation, who knows, but it isn’t the same as any GDs I’ve tried. I grow a Starkspur, my sister grows a generic, the Golden Harvest tested as GD. They all taste somewhat different.

Hawaii

Yellow apple with great taste (hint of banana to me). No acid to speak of. Has had no growing or fruiting issues so far. Mid September ripening. Two trees on M111 and still somewhat young. Northern Va not far from Leesburg, Va. zone 7a. Hawaii is something I would recommend to anyone and just a great fresh eating apple. One of my favorites.

1 Like

Any issues with excessive premature fruit drop?

This is one the most irritating issues for me with nearly every variety.

No excessive dropping.
Premature dropping is not really a problem for me here. My issues are rots, PC, and FB

2 Likes

I dont think we will convince everyone..

If anyone cares i think this is the true story- with Yellow Delicious being a synonym by any nursery other than Stark Bros. selling the same apple.

However anyone chasing something better might want to go down this path (rabbit hole).

1 Like

I really don’t care about the origins Yellow D vs Gold D or who sold what. All I can tell is there is stark difference between the two trees that I own(ed). I still have a Starkspur GD and have had it for about 18 years and had the Yellow D for 15-16 years at the very same time. I’m just conveying what I observed. That is all.

Knowing what is diploid, sterile, triploid, self-fertile, partial self-fertile is very important information for the backyard grower.

The point of this whole thread is to provide an unvarnished assessment of certain apples grown in certain places for the benefit of the reader. I’m not influencing or selling. Everyone in the business is still learning while sifting through a lot of information and misinformation.

1 Like