What is a true orange?

One interesting detail is that some languages have the word orange for the color but don’t use that name for the fruit. German for example.

I’m pretty sure these studies are kinda over sold. There was a lot of popularity in academia historically, and honestly to this day in a lot of soft sciences, that language basically precedes perception. But like, it’s honestly mostly a contrived theory that relies on obfuscation and dense terminology to try and win arguments through bewilderment basically.

There are some cases when it sort of makes sense, but usually it’s stuff like the secondary associated qualities of abstractions, like if you perceive heartbreak as your heart breaking (English) or being squeezed (Japanese) or even just your chest burning (Arabic).

Counterexamples are much more straightforward and clear: you can see the difference between light blue and dark blue even though to you they’re both just blue (English) while to others they are two completely different colors (most Slavic languages).

The physiological process occurring in your eyes doesn’t care what sounds your mouth makes, basically.

3 Likes

Perhaps but there are studies showing Russians are faster at distinguishing shades of blue, plausibly because of their language. Im not suggesting that people literally cant see a difference, more that it isnt distinguished Your Language Could Make It Easier to Tell Different Colors Apart : ScienceAlert

2 Likes

Thank you, JohannsGarden, for seeing the forest!

4 Likes

@Audi_o_phile @JohannsGarden

I’m only making the distinction because science has determined without a doubt the parentage. What is hybrid and what is not. What humans developed they are confident about. It really only makes a difference if you are thinking in terms of the future of hybrid crosses to come. They have sequenced what has already been done and that indicates what will be done in the future. A mandarin orange is the parent and the offspring crossed with pomelo and grapefruit are called oranges. A Mandelo might be a better name. Some oranges are poor quality like the sour orange and some taste good like the sweet orange. The orange color of mandarin or oranges would make more sense if they called a lime a green or pomelo a yellow. I do find it very interesting.

3 Likes

…but this would not explain the rainbow.

Red-orange-yellow-green-blue-indigo-violet.
So now I wonder if the ancient cultures had words for all seven rainbow bands.

To my eyes, the orange is more distinctive in the R-O-Y bands than is the indigo in the B-I-V bands.

1 Like

isn’t a true orange grow from seed? You personally sprout the seed. You nature it into a seedling. You pour your water, fertilizer, and your strength to form a 10 years bond. After 10 years bond, the seedling give you the sweet fruits you are hoping for. You grow a magnificent tree to last your life time.

2 Likes

I guess you could wait a long time for a seed. Or take things into your own hands, a sharp knife, two plants; and get fruit in 3-4 years. I doubt the orange would be “less true”.

2 Likes

Keep in mind that “Orange” also has an actual legal definition in Florida (and possibly USDA, can’t remember). So even though scientists have developed new Mandarin varieties, they cannot create any new “Orange” varieties. They can only improve existing lines. So they cannot even recreate the fruit through hybridization and call it an orange. So the new ones are “orange-like hybrids” and cannot be used for juice solely, only in certain percentages for blends.

7 Likes

Which is unfortunate. To my mind, the botanical classification of what an orange is is somewhat contrived, as with any species complex. That leaves the culinary classification, which is usable (a particular taste, texture, and aroma) but fuzzy with a lot of grey area.

Sure, there were specific hybridization events that occurred historically or prehistorically from which all “true” oranges are descended. But other than that specific pedigree, is there anything unique about those lines? If so, what is unique? The only thing I can think of is the flavor, but at that point what we’re actually doing is using a culinary definition to justify a genealogical one, which is pretty silly. What happens if a new hybrid ends up having the same flavor? But if you drop the culinary aspect, then it really is just an arbitrary list of mandarin pummelo hybrids that get to be oranges.

It’s not like oranges are the only hybrids between pummelo and mandarin. There are plenty of things like New Zealand Grapefruit which are also pummelo and mandarin, as are Hassaku, Nataudaidai, etc. and many of them can be quite similar to sweet orange. Beyond that, many “mandarins” are actually mandarin pummelo hybrids backcrossed to mandarin. There’s basically a gradient of pummelo introgression from those with a lot like Ponkan and Khasi to those with less but still some like satsumas, with pure mandarins mostly being a few wild sour mandarins.

Personally, I think in the long term having strict legal definitions for agricultural and culinary things becomes counterproductive or even harmful. Some degree of order and protection is necessary for good business, sure, but it’s very easy to go overboard. And for what? I don’t really care if my orange juice was made from the fruit of trees descended from some specific tree, and I really don’t care if it has a specific chemical composition of flavor and aroma compounds as mandated by law. Just let them sell what they can best produce and let me taste it and I’ll buy the brand that I like. So long as it’s being made from the fruit of real trees that are majority pummelo and mandarin genetically, and it tastes good and in the ballpark of what I grew up drinking, I think we’re fine.

8 Likes

I find otherwise useless trifoliate oranges as good ammunition to get in Orange fights with our farm neighbor’s hired hand. He never learns…lol

5 Likes

That’s borderline chemical warfare

4 Likes

He is lucky my arm is more cheese then arm these days.

4 Likes

Even lots of people that grew up in California don’t understand the vast amounts of land from the Mexican border to above Sacramento that has supplied food and citrus to the nation and world.

Historically, California citrus thrived across dozens of decentralized counties until postwar suburban sprawl forced growers to abandon Southern California. Today, the multi-billion-dollar industry has migrated north, anchoring its massive fresh-fruit empire securely within the Central Valley’s diverse agricultural network.

A quick search brought me here which really surprised me.

According to the [USDA National Agricultural Statistics Service August 2026 Citrus Fruits Summary] California now accounts for 84% of the total United States citrus market.
The remaining domestic market is split between:

  • Florida: 13%
    *** Texas & Arizona: 3% combined**
    When looking strictly at the fresh-fruit market (the actual oranges, mandarins, and lemons you buy raw in a grocery store rather than juice), California’s dominance climbs even higher, supplying roughly 90% to 95% of the entire country’s fresh commercial inventory. This massive share is driven by record-breaking mandarin crops and Florida’s continued acreage struggles with citrus greening disease and storm recovery.

What’s left are a few counties up North including Placer and Sacramento more boutique growers and lots of citrus festivals. And these guys holding it down for the markets.

  • Tulare County (The largest producer; dominates fresh oranges and mandarins)
  • Kern County (Second-largest producer; major hub for seedless mandarins and oranges)
  • Fresno County (Massive commercial yields of oranges, lemons, and mandarins)
  • Ventura County (The coastal powerhouse; leads the state in lemon production)
  • Riverside County (Major grower of grapefruit, pummelos, and desert lemons)
  • Imperial County (Specializes in winter desert lemons and early grapefruit)
  • San Diego County (Significant yields of premium coastal lemons and specialty citrus)
5 Likes

Taxonomy, including species designations, is just a human invention; the natural world being much more complex, with some plants occupying relative positions on a spectrum, rather than clear-cut points of their own. I once was taught that a “specie” designation was used to separately group plants/animals apart from other species based on their inability to interbreed. As I look at the whole citrus genus, it appears to be just one big specie, with multiple landraces due to temporary historical isolation, with later occasional re-mixing, both natural and man-made. The diversity among apples is as great as it is in citrus, yet they are largely considered one specie.

4 Likes

I was once told that “genus” was used to designate which plants could theoretically pollinate one another. I have since come to conclusion that the most useful use of scientific name is for googling fruits that share common names, like custard apples (which is like every species of Annona) and pitaya/night bloom cereus (which is like every species of Cacti).

3 Likes