I bought a bunch of pomegranates and olive trees from Rolling River in spring 2014, and it seems like quite a few of those were mislabeled. It’s very frustrating. I’m going to replace what they sent me as Bala Miursal, Hotuni Zigar, and Phoenicia, since I don’t like the fruit, but it’s possible those have been mislabeled, so don’t want to trash the cultivars. I also tried Phoenicia at a tasting in the Wolfskill Experimental Orchard in Winters, CA, and it was too acidic for my taste. I reported on my experience at this tasting here: Pomegranate tasting at Wolfskill Experimental Orchard, 2016
I’ve had very good success rooting pomegranate cuttings (from CRFG scion exchanges in the SF Bay area), and I expect those should be true to label. I will plant them as replacements.