The really fireblight resistant pears are a short list

@hambone

Im not sure that is FB. It really does not look like it. There is no blackness there. If it was which i dont think it is i would carve it out with a knife.

This is fireblight Fire Blight | Triangle Gardener Magazine

2 Likes

Yes, that’s the form I’m used to seeing. Maybe I’ll carve out or blowtorch what “may” be FB on Potomac and see what happens. Thank You!

1 Like

@hambone soak them down with copper and see what shakes out this year. I prefer kocide 3000

Kocide while dormant, right? In addition to cutting/torching or in place of?

1 Like

I had 2 Magness pears. One received less morning sun and had multiple strikes last year despite copper, pruning and no fertilizer. It managed to set a few pears but later in summer developed fb on main trunk. We removed it. The other one gets great morning sun and has thrived except for a few easily removed strikes. Warren is proving to be very fb resistant here.

1 Like

Same here. Blakes Pride is a dud here.

1 Like

@clarkinks Clark you were right- my Potomac did NOT have fire blight but just harmless bark fissures from normal growth plus wind torque on certain branches. Big relief. Had local tree expert inspect today. All clear. Fabulous. He called it “bark enlarging” or something like that.

3 Likes

@hambone

Good news and about what i was suspecting. Fireblight is the first thing we all think of because it is a problem. Potomac is pretty tough!

@clarkinks if you had to choose between Harrow Sweet and Potomac for FB resistance which would you choose? I have a Harrow sweet ordered…but Potomac has my interest and reading through threads I’m on the fence as to which would perform best. Thanks for any advice

1 Like

@Paul-VA

I think potomac is more resistant. Harrow sweet and potomac are both delicious.

1 Like

Considering Patten, Parker or Summer crisp for zone 3b. Are any of these resistant to fireblight?

So there is a pear tree 2 doors down that gets fire blight each year. I have no idea what type pear it is. The FB doesn’t kill the tree. It did set fruit this year, so it may be partially self fertile. See photo below.

The good news so far is I have an Asian pear now with 9 additional varieties grafted that sits about 90 feet away and has not shown any signs of FB yet, neither with new growth from the previous years grafts nor this years grafts.

FB tree

My tree

Many pear varieties appear to never get fireblight, but are not resistant. A tree that gets it but recovers without major damage is demonstrating resistance. Keiffer is a known example often hit by fireblight, but never succumbing.

2 Likes

Has your tree flowered yet? If not watch it very closely for FB when it does.

1 Like

No flowers this year.

I thought FB hits new growth in general when it’s on the cooler and wet side weather wise.

I have a smaller 3-on-1 Asian pear in my backyard that has set a few fruit. Went through flowering with no FB. Of course that doesn’t mean it won’t get a strike, or in another year.

Firelight usually does not hit a pear tree until at least it’s first bloom, I think that the blooms might have something to do with the fireblight bacteria infecting the tree.

1 Like

The FB mainly enters the tree through the flowers then it moves within the tree until it gets to young tender growth that is susceptible to its evil ways. I think it can also directly enter tender growth via wounds from insects, wind damage or hail damage, but I think it’s mainly through the flowers. That’s good that your other tree has some fruit and no FB. Keep a close eye on it because it can take a couple of weeks after it enters the flowers to build up enough population to cause visible signs. I’m picking off lots of infected apple clusters this week that looked fine til now. Fruit is pea to small marble size. If it was me I’d only let shoot tip flowers open next year on your grafts that way you can cut it way back and not lose the grafts. Then relax a little more on that each year.

1 Like

Thanks for the insights.

Even without that neighbor’s pear I mentioned, it’s always going to be present where I live. I’d say the good thing about having 11 varieties on 2 trees is that I will be able to tell which ones do better with the FB.

Hopefully the ones that don’t do well don’t kill the tree outright.

1 Like

If you list your pears readers can comment on blight experiences.

1 Like

Shinseiki, Yakumo, Raja, Korean Giant, Pai Li, Ya Li, Shinko, Chojuro, Hosui, 20th Century, Atago.

:grin: