Bob, I used chips this time because that’s what I had; last time on the small plum I used a combination from the chainsaw and the shop. Here’s a link to that post that describes the original info I had. I really don’t know if this is better than leaving it out in the open, which is usually my preference. https://growingfruit.org/t/surprise-girdle-recovery/23850
I also don’t know just what ingredients in Fedco’s formula does the trick. The combination I’m using has all parts - oil/quick lime/milk/clay/water. It does seem to make a pretty good barrier - doesn’t wash off after it’s dried. I wish you the best with your trees! Hopefully they will recover once the borers are removed. Sue