Surprise Girdle Recovery

This past winter I had a vole get inside a hardware cloth cage on a nice 2 yr chum sucker, removing bark 2" all the way around, about 2" up from ground. Though disappointing it wasn’t a big loss as I have a lot of chum suckers. When I found it this spring I was just going to cut it off and let it grow another since I wanted one in that spot. Then I remembered a post I’d saved from a NAFEX forum member. This is what she said:
“[Info received by poster from another member] To repair an injury to a tree trunk, create a window screen wire fence around the tree. The size of this should be at least 6” from trunk to screen wire for small tree (1-3” dia.), 8-12” for larger trees. Make sure the screen goes at least 12” above the injury and all the way to the ground. The diagram shows the screen cut at the bottom and flanged out to help the assembly stay in place. Fill inside the screen wire fence to 12” above the injury with fresh sawdust, preferably Pine. Aftercare: Leave in place for 2 years minimum for small trees; up to 6 years for larger trees.

[Her experience] … all the trees were on M111 rootstock. They varied in age, but most were over 4 years old. … two had been girdled [below ground]. The others had various levels of damage, and a few even had damage somewhat above the ground. Some trees were leaning badly due to the root loss from the voles. To save them, we first staked the trees that were leaning. All I had was fresh hardwood shavings, and no window screen., so I proceeded to stack the fresh hardwood shavings around the trees as high as needed (per instructions). I knew that rain, etc. would gradually move the stacked shavings down because there was nothing to hold them, so I planned to restack, but this was not needed much. I did this “stacking” around seven trees.

Results: All the trees were improved by this treatment. The girdled trees did not die, and did grow replacement bark. It seemed that the stacking method also helped with the vole problem. One that was girdled was a Black Limbertwig. It was staked because it had lost so much structure underground that it was easily moved if you put your hand on it. I did not have much faith that it would pull through. Notes state, “If [the sawdust cure] saves the Black Limbertwig, it will be a miracle.” After several years, that tree started bearing fruit. We harvested some this year. The whole thing is counter-intuitive to me (stacking shavings against a trunk), but it worked.”

Well, I figured it wouldn’t hurt to give it a try. This was early April. I swept up as much fine pine sawdust as I could find in the shop, put a layer of newspaper around inside the hardware cloth cage and filled it with the sawdust. The trunk of this chum was only about a foot before branching and I didn’t have a lot of sawdust but it came about 2" above the girdled area.

The tree did have a significant amount of aphid/ant activity at the ends of all the branches, more than the other plums, but it did fine through the summer and regrew leaves when the aphids abated in August. The ants loved the sawdust hotel. I forgot that the initial instructions were to leave it be for two years so mid August I took the cage off, spreading sawdust and ants around under the tree, not having any real expectations. To my great surprise all I could see was bark. I spread some DE around to knock back the ants so I could get in there to look and sure enough - bark - all around. Lighter color having been out of the sun all summer, and I can feel a small indent at the edges of the girdled area but basically it looks normal and as healthy as the other suckers around. Wow!

Wish I’d tried this on a few other partially girdled trees/shrubs that didn’t fare nearly as well. I’d certainly do it again. Of course, hopefully there will not be any need. Since I’ve had a weasel(s) hanging around the garden/orchard all summer (based on scats) it should be an easier winter that way. But I’ll still be putting hardware cages around everything, and hope for a more “normal” (less than 2 ft) snow year. Sue

10 Likes

A truly useful suggestion - thank you!

1 Like

I wish I was able to try this, I lost 15 apples and 5 plums to vole damage last spring. I have copied and pasted these directions, if that is OK? At least it is some type of action, it is so hard to look at the trees and feel helpless.

I am looking for a good way to deter the mice and voles on multi trunk trees, as yet hardware cages seem to be the only solution but it is hard to apply on espalier branches or multi trunk trees.

I was toying with the idea of using those black foam insulation tubes for plumbing, they come with a slit. Maybe if I use them in combination with the hardware cloth I can keep the wire from damaging the bark?

2 Likes

Congrats on your success. What is a chum sucker? I haven’t seen that term before.

1 Like

@quill - That’s short for cherry plum. Mine are Sapalta and they sucker like american plums. If I could train the voles to only eat the ones I don’t want I’d be all set.

@northof53 - On a couple of multi trunks I wrapped the trunks with some old brass window screen i had which worked. On a few others i just made big cages which didn’t always keep them out I’ve also gone to short single trunks when possible.

I also wish I’d tried this sooner! Though i didn’t have the losses you had. Even though the vole population has gone down after the explosion we had winter before last (thanks in probably large part to a barred owl that moved in that year and now an active weasel that’s taken up residence) I’ll still cage everything i can come fall. Sue

6 Likes

I have 2 nut trees and an apple tree that were about 3/4 girdled a month ago by im assuming half grown rabbits that were able to slip threw my tree cages. I wonder if this would still work to heal them or if its been too long? Ive actually been wondering if they will pull threw with that much girdling, they’re 50 dollar trees so i really hope so.

Seems like it would certainly be worth a try. It would be great if it would work. A lot probably also depends on the extent of damage. But I’d do it anyway. Miracles happen! Sue

1 Like

In my experience here, whenever apple trees are loose it is pine-vole damage and the scion does not get girdled. M111 does repair itself, but losing almost all the roots is at least a 2 year set-back and often more (depending on whether trees are irrigated and otherwise pampered).

Trees that are completely girdled above the graft union have always died, but even if meadow voles girdle the rootstock just below the graft union they can recover. Trees also usually can survive even with a small strip of cambium unsevered. The healing process leaves them stronger than ever and resistant to future vole damage.

However, on my sisters property in coastal far northern CA, I’ve seen apple trees completely stripped of lower bark by goats still alive years later- I mean the bottom 3’! I assume because of the very moist air. The trees had very little vigor, but they were under the canopy of other trees and entirely neglected. I don’t know if they could have become truly functional trees again or not. When rabbits have done similar damage here the trees are dead by mid-spring, if not out of winters box.

2 Likes

Thanks for this post, I have some trees with some rootstock damage, and may have to try this procedure.

I have been weeding some woefully neglected apple trees the last couple of days, and to my chagrin most of them have a degree of damage to the rootstocks. I don’t know if it’s winter sunscald damage or rodent or insect damage, but it doesn’t look good on a couple of my trees. I kinda think it’s sunscald because there are small strips of bark that have been shed, or are loose.

After close up inspection, I"ve also seen some kind of insects in the wood, I don’t know if they’re the cause of the problem, or have been exploiting the damage from other means.

Here are a few pics of some worms that I have seen crawling around on the damaged bark and on the ground, they have black bodies and a red head. I’ve looked online and can’t figure out what they might be. Anyone want to venture a guess?

Do you think my trees can recover from this damage to the rootstocks? They are all 4th leaf trees on Geneva rootstocks (G16, G202, and G222). The worst damage is to a G16 Grimes Golden. It actually has produced a few small apples this year for the first time. The bark right at the soil line looks like it’s been chewed on almost all the way around the rootstock. Does that sound more like rodent damage than insects? I’ll try to post some pics of the trees.

Those look like soldier beetle larvae, shouldn’t be the problem.

I had a container fig stripped of about 60% of its bark this winter. Thought it was a goner but they didn’t gnaw all the way down to the wood so the cambium recovered nicely without doing anything to it. Others were not so lucky of course, maybe sawdust or paint or a wrap could have helped…

1 Like

Thanks, that’s what it look like on the interwebs. It’s actually a beneficial bug, so now I’m thinking this damage is sunscald and/or vole/mole gnawing. Sure hope my trees aren’t goners, some of those rootstocks look like they were chewed on pretty good (bad).

I had a Suncrisp and Macoun gnawed on by rabbits in March, don’t know if they’ll recover or not. The SC was almost completely girdled, so it may be doomed, but I think the Macoun will be OK.

These trees I’ve been working on these last few days were inside wire cages, so it shouldn’t be rabbits, the gaps in the fencing is 1x2 inches, but that wouldn’t keep smaller rodents out. The SC and Macoun didn’t have any protection so that was stupid on my part.

Before winter looks like I’ll need to put some finer mesh wire screening around all my trees’ lower trunks. I’ve had battles with deer, now they’re not as big a problem, but now it’s rodents.

I also have about a 15ft tall Winesap with no leaves on it now, it has what looks like some kind of root rot right at ground level. I couldn’t see any obvious rodent damage. The bark passes the scratch test, but it is basically barren of leaves.

By next spring I may end up with a few less apple trees. But, I have 6 more in pots that I’ve bench grafted over the last two years, so I have some replacements. Not exact swaps, but better than nothing- Goldrush, Stayman, Suncrisp, Honeycrisp, Enterprise, and Mollies Delicious.

2 Likes

It sucks to have trees dying and no clear explanation. I have too little to go on to offer an explanation to your issues, not that I would have one anyway. Obviously if there is clear bark damage, something is eating it. I’ve never had a problem with rodents during the growing season. If gnawing isn’t clear, maybe your problem is fungal. Insect borers should leave some kind of tunnels.

Around here a 2.5 year monsoon caused considerable damage, and even though we’ve had a relatively normal summer, even some drought at the moment, there’s a lot of defoliation of trees as a result of Marsoninna leaf blotch and perhaps other fungus issues. Leaves gradually drop off trees with lots of yellow, red and just dark blotches.

If leaves are on trees until near Aug, they usually survive early defoliation but I believe it reduces productivity.

Thanks. Well, I haven’t inspected these trees until now, so they could have been damaged by rodents last winter and I’m just now seeing it.

I didn’t mention that there was some sawdust looking material by some of the rootstocks, some call it frass on here. So, I think there’s some borers doing some damage, even though I don’t see any such critters nearby, other than what looks like a small grayish roly-poly type bug on the wood. Since it appears I have some kind of borers, what’s the method of control?

We have also had very wet conditions here for the last few years, which I’m sure has contributed to some root issues. Some of these trees I’ve weeded lately get a bit of standing water nearby after very heavy rains. But I have never seen the trunks standing in water, even tho I’m sure the water table is pretty high underneath them sometimes.

I haven’t seen any real root issues with these trees, just my big Winesap. That tree is in another location and it has been in some very wet soil over its lifetime, so I’m guessing some kind of root rot. It never has totally leafed out this year, and the few leaves that did are gone. Since it’s been so dry this summer here, a lot of trees are dropping leaves, but this one is bare.

Sorry to hear about your trees. It is disappointing to lose them just when they are finally about to get some fruit.

3 Likes