Apple Grower Interview: Can you water new fruit trees too much?

Since right now is a good time to plant dormant fruit trees, I thought I’d share part of an interview I did about three weeks ago with an organic apple and cherry grower here in Washington.

His name is Nestor Garcia, and he had all kinds of things to share. This is just one segment of our conversation, where we talked about establishing new fruit trees. He shared two tips based on what’s worked for him in his orchard.

Interview: https://youtu.be/q-h-rvxlPi8?si=6hcu4Gk1I5duww5Y

After you’ve had a chance to watch, I’d be curious to hear whether you agree or disagree with his advice, and how it compares with your own experience.

5 Likes

The man is an expert… in one soil type and on trees with seriously size reducing rootstock. It is impossible to evaluate his methods because he is not really describing comparisons of different treatments.

Keeping soils that are not fast draining soaking wet is not a universal prescription for rapid establishment of anything except maybe rice. Many of the soils in his region are extremely porous so may not suffer from near constant watering, but that doesn’t mean it is necessary for fastest growth and I’m unaware of any research that suggests it is.

I’m a little more experienced than the gentleman being interviewed, but he is successful in a realm in which I have no experience. Commercial fruit growing is another country from managing scores of home orchards in a wide range of soil types and microclimates along with running a very small, bearing age fruit tree nursery (as a dry farmer in the east). My well doesn’t have enough water to keep the soil trees are growing in soaked all growing season, but sometimes the rain is pretty persistent throughout. But that just keeps the soil moist, not soaking wet.

Fertigation’s main advantage, as I see it, is if you are drip irrigating your trees anyway it allows precision that will reduce any waste- however, most soils are capable (maybe not his) of holding N. for long enough to not to require constant fertilzation for max growth.

3 Likes

i couldnt maintain that level of watering here without killing my trees. my heavy clay holds water even in drought. ive realized too that clay has alot of nutrients in it . why my apples grow so quickly with near 0 water, plus im in a pretty rainy area. this summer we were in a severe drought yet all my apples and pears put out alot of fruit for thieir ages. i only water newly planted fruit trees when is hot and dry out. other than that they get a good woodchip mulch and they establish just fine. in sandy soil or in really dry areas i can see the benefit to his procedure. also in our cold weather, its best to not fertilize the 1st season as it makes the new growth prone to cold damage.

4 Likes

Yes, clay initially tends to contain much more nutrients than coarser soils and also holds onto added N than coarser soils. What I didn’t like about the early part of the interview was it seemed the man assumed his methods were universal- that he know the perfect prescription for growers everywhere.

In an average soil the only nutrient that will speed growth is nitrogen. In a sand gravel soil N does not stick around for long.

2 Likes

This is a guideline from Ariz. U.

Nitrogen application frequency by soil texture

Soil texture Recommended N applications per crop
Clay, sandy clay, silty clay, clay loam, silty clay loam 1–2
Silt, silt loam, sandy clay loam 2–4
Sandy loam, loamy sand 3–5
Sand
1 Like

I’d say he’s giving good advice for his soil, climate, and goals. In the first year his goal is to maximize tree growth. That does take a lot of water or maybe more correctly frequent watering. New trees that stop growing due to a short dry spell may be done growing for that year. And he is talking drip so not wetting a big area.

That said the advice isn’t very universal. In a poorer draining soil it could be a disaster. I might give similar advice but with less emphasis on the flooding part. And a lot more concern about overdoing it.

I did something similar with apples in CA on a very sandy soil. I pushed Pink Lady M9 very hard the first year with frequent water and nitrogen. The trees grew great and in the second year had so much fruit that I was flabbergasted. Like 30 lbs per tree. That’s just what he’s trying to do only sweet cherries take another year to set flower buds. Fruit quality was poor. Maybe too much nitrogen.

I once worked with commercial apple growers in west Texas. These were big growers with center pivots and lots of water. So they pushed their field crops to high yields by watering on a ~3 day schedule. My furrow watered sugarbeets were watered every 14 days. His yields beat mine. With apples it didn’t work so well with frequent drip. His trees grew great but fireblight took him out of business in short order after investing 30K per acre. I never had fireblight in 30 years in that area with less intensive watering. The cherry grower could get blindsided by something similar with his flooding protocal.

4 Likes

@ThePollinator Does Nestor also have new apples trees or is it just the cherries that are the new orchard? Wondering if he has the same comparison for apple trees as for cherry trees.

I think it’s really hard for commercial growers to make a profit these days unless they do high density with these fast producing dwarfing rootstocks.

All the advice for the high density systems is to push the trees really hard the first year to get production started ASAP to get a profit.

Also, a bunch of us noticed this year/last year that the Geneva rootstocks do really really poorly when they’re young if they’re not watered constantly.

Yikes! And this is probably why all the apples are now from the dry parts of washington state!

2 Likes

In what soil? Where? How were the trees installed? Without that, the advice is worse than no advice, IMO. Washington State U. guidelines do not call for constant watering of anything and their irrigations guidelines take into account the texture of the soil. Very few things are one size fits all in growing fruit trees. I would like to see a single piece of research that shows trees thrive best in soil that is constantly soaking wet. I suspect it works well when your soil is so porous it is almost like hydroponic growing. I can’t know though, because I have no soil descriptions at all to work with.

Of course commercial growers seek to get trees into full production as soon as possible and trellis systems are expensive so a quick return is going to be important. But this is not a forum for commercial growers in WA State and to provide unqualified advice (that is without explaining what specific soil and weather conditions the methods are based on) doesn’t seem helpful to the members here who are from all over the country. The majority of us grow trees and not bushes anyway.

I have never had trees on any rootstock suffer water deprivation in normal soils when I dress them with about 5 cubic feet of compost under the same of shredded wood mulch in my humid region- but certainly watering them through periods of drought speed their growth. The mulch is a common thing used for establishing landscape trees in my region and not something a commercial grower is likely to use- let alone the compost. Both of these are good reservoirs for water.

1 Like

Okay, fair point. I probably should have said “consistently”.

I’m pretty sure the first time I saw this it was here:

But then I kept seeing other references to this. I also got a similar message in an email exchange with Cummins.

2 Likes

That they need “heavy, heavy” watering? To me that is nonsense. Once the soil is saturated what are you doing?. I’m planting bare root trees right now without any additional water because the soil is already moist everywhere I’m planting and this is how I’ve done it for many years. Some sites have automatic sprinkler systems and those don’t do better than sites without, unless trees are neglected during long stretches of drought, particularly in spring.

I have seen a lot more trees killed by excess water than too little. But I live in the humid region of this country. Rain killed a couple of trees in my nursery this year, in fact- in the wettest part of my land. If soil makes mud when it’s wet you have to be careful not to over water.

1 Like

Here.. most fruit trees I plant get watered once after planting… and that is it.

Hard to over water that way.

I do mulch them really good.

He must live in a very different … much dryer location than I do.

TNHunter

3 Likes

I think guys like @alan are missing the main idea a bit by focusing too much on how Nestor’s situation is different from whoever else’s. Nestor’s main point is to give the first year trees maximum water without compromising airflow. Nestor himself said if you water it so that ‘it’s flooded half of the time, without water standing, super wet, the tree will grow phenomenal.’ He’s aware that there is such thing as too much water and by extension not enough air. He is not recommending watering excessively in a poorly draining soil. He’s just saying - maximum water without losing too much air = more growth and eventual fruiting wood. It’s a natural principle we see in plants. When does a plant grow more? When it is rainy? Or when it is dry?

What he’s trying to do is get as much vegetative growth that the cherry trees will put forth so that same growth will convert into more fruiting wood, and thus more cherries, sooner. That’s it.

2 Likes

The answer to this question is location and grower dependent.

2 Likes

Look, the goal is always to sustain the perfect balance between air and water in the soil. The protical relies on either using a moisture sensor or learn to use your own hands, although it is hard to reach deep enough to know exactly what’s going on below.

If you find his guidelines helpful, that is fine, I did not find what I saw and heard as being adequately descriptive, but that’s just me.

2 Likes

Alan, it sounds like your biggest concern is that someone might watch this interview, take Nestor’s advice at face value, and end up doing more harm than good to their trees.

I can see how sharing his watering practices without enough information about his soil, drainage, and growing conditions could give people the wrong impression.

And it probably looks like I’m presenting a commercial grower’s methods as advice everyone should follow, without considering what people here have learned from their own experiences.

I really appreciate you taking the time to share your concerns. After talking with Nestor, I did some additional research because I knew his approach wouldn’t work everywhere. But I’m realizing there are still some questions I need to ask him.

I’m curious what you think would be most important to clarify.

3 Likes

He’s focusing on planting cherries right now, and I have another segment of the interview which I’ll share, where he talks about why. He also has a Golden Delicious block, but right now he’s not planting any new apples.

3 Likes

We know that. Not everyone does. I don’t think we are who Nestor had in mind when giving this advice. And, on the specifics we are more in line with each other than with Nestor because we’re in similar environments.

When I listened to people like Paul Gautschi or Peter Zeihan who make big sweeping generalizations I learned to get better at extracting the main idea they’re conveying even if there are technicalities they miss. Since I’m used to that way of speaking, I’m kinda relaxed about the details.

3 Likes

I would have issues watering as much as the grower in the video recommends, but then I also have clay soil. In spring there’s often standing water while things thaw out. I compost then mulch heavily and that helps moderate things. I’m not trying to maximize production, though, just a home grower.

With regards to Geneva, hoping to not derail the thread, I have 969 and 890 in our back orchard with MM111 and haven’t noticed a big difference in irrigation needs. I watered them intermittently their first year in ground (spring 2023) because it was a very hot, dry summer, but can’t say I did a great job with it, and they seem to be on track.

@ThePollinator do you find this irrigation advice to be true at home/other, if you do have an orchard or fruit trees you’re tending to separately?

2 Likes

For the record, I have NOT practiced “heavy, heavy watering” with Geneva root stocks. In order to water at my orchard I have to haul 230 Gal totes in the pickup or trailer, and quite frankly that’s a pain in the keester. I’ve watered in trees as I was planting them (if the soil wasn’t already damp), or transplanting them, but never have I watered a tree in the orchard once it’s in the ground. As with Alan, my climate just doesn’t require it. I do recall some exchanges with Cummin’s about G.210 specifically, but not Geneva RS in general. In that quote they also warn against too much water, but if I recall correctly that was in relation to bench grafting and leaving the RS’s in a bucket of water overnight.

4 Likes

Buckeye, we used to have some fruit trees at home, but eventually took them out because we’re in a cold pocket and the blossoms kept getting hit by frost. So no, I haven’t personally tried Nestor’s watering approach.

I’ve spent about 17 years working in commercial fruit pollination, so I’ve gotten to know many growers over the years. But there’s still a lot that I don’t know, which is one reason I wanted to start doing these interviews.

And I’ve been learning a lot from the discussion here, too. I appreciate you sharing how you’ve managed your trees.

5 Likes