Best tasting crabapple?

Anyone here ever heard of or grown Narrangansett crab from fedco? It sounds like a good one potentially.


Fall. Unknown origin. This ornamental crab was mistakenly added to the Maine Heritage Orchard collection years ago. We were after the extremely rare full sized York County apple with the same name, but once this one set fruit we decided to keep it. It was too good to replace!

When the buds begin to swell in spring they are carmine red, opening up to fragrant white flowers blushed with pink. Not usually planted for its small bright orange-scarlet, long stemmed fruit, but it is surprisingly good for fresh eating. Juicy, citrusy and not too tart. Whatever you don’t eat will hang on the tree well into the winter providing nourishing treats for the birds.

Good grower with a pleasing compact ovular shape. Highly disease resistant. Blooms midseason. Z4

5 Likes

Narrangansett is so good. Complex crabbiness and nostalgic flavors that are sort of reminiscent of ice pops. It also has a great growth habit in terms of compactness, branch angles, and precociousness. Nice firm texture, kept well in the fridge for a few months. Highly recommend!

6 Likes

Awesome, where did you get your tree/scion from? How does it do with disease resistance?

Just found this crab growing near here, probably a seedling:

Quite tasty - slightly on the sweet side with a hint of tannins, very flavorful. White flesh, tender skin. They might can nicely.

9 Likes

I traded scions with a friend that works at the Maine Heritage Orchard, my interest was peaked after seeing them share some info about the tree online & also hearing reports back from friends that tried the fruit. They sent me 4 scions in 2023 and I have just been regrafting any new growth, I have 20+ trees at this point and will be planting them out in the coming weeks. In the nursery - the leaves have been super healthy, with short internodes. It seems to flower on last years growth.

3 Likes

Naragansett was the best apple I tasted when I visited Maine Heritage Orchard last week. Plan to get some scion wood for next spring!

1 Like

To me, Centennial tastes like apple juice. It’s a kid’s apple, very cute and oval, not a speck of bitterness or acidity. I like Wickson but can’t seem to keep them alive, so just tried grafting to 2 different rootstocks this spring. Almata is a geat tasting, pretty red fleshed apple, but doesn’t store well. I would recommend it as a niche early apple to sell to high-end restaurants or bakeries for seasonal desserts.

2 Likes

I just grafted that this past spring from Fedco - glad to hear an endorsement!

1 Like

I actually dont see it on Fedco’s website this year…wonder why

At least some of Fedco’s offerings change each year it seems.

1 Like

@LarisaLee - Almata is the only red-fleshed crab that I’ve grown that anyone would want to eat, out-of-hand.

1 Like

When we went out west this fall… in Jackson hole Wyoming… just off the main drag… near the place we stayed at (a cabin)… there was a crabapple just off the sidewalk in front of a business there.

When we walked by there were 2-3 young folks there with a small ladder and they were picking crab apples off a tree there.

It was mid September and they were just starting to ripen good. Oh man… they were delicious. They gave us a few and said pick what you want. I picked more every time we passed by.

I wondered if it might be Chestnut or some other variety ?

I was wishing I could collect some scion wood from it… the flavor was quite addicting… made me crave them.

TNHunter

4 Likes

Chestnut has become one of my favourites. Who knew it would survive our -40C temps. I find that once the weather in the fall gets cold, almost freezing, those crabs have an intense flavour.

6 Likes

I am assuming by best tasting you are seeking small apples vs traditional crab apples that are acidic and tannin.

My favourite small apple so far is Trailman. Crisp and juicy. Sweet with balanced acidity. Delicious complex flavour.

Cold hardy to -34C

Biggest downside is drops easy when ripe. It is an early apple. Ready late August here in 4b Canada (USDA 3b).

2 Likes

I often ski up in the area… if you can give message me a location, I “might” be able to get some sticks during dormant season.

2 Likes

@Toadham

There it is… just past the hood of that car in that little patch of green grass.
Found it with Google Street View.

It is on West Pearl Ave just down from Big Hole BBQ… in front of the Teton Conservation District building. This is just a short distance off the Town Square and the Elk Horn arches.

I will find a spot for a new apple tree if you can get me some scion of that.

Will be glad to send you any scion I have in trade.

Thanks
TNHunter

4 Likes

These crabapples are growing along an exit ramp. Grafted as they also produce some red ones at a different time. Any ideas on variety? taste good but skin is a bit tough. I plan to collect scion this winter.


4 Likes

^^^Those look like small apples to me

Likely apple crab. State does not plant apples along interstate highway just crabs and apple crabs as ornamentals.

2 Likes

It could’ve been a mislabel. Someone just posted fruit from a golden delicious in a parking lot because it was in with a pack of landscaping crabs

2 Likes