Steve333 - thanks for sharing. On varieties, I’d think most that do well for you will do even better down here, though you might have some slight advantage with staying consistently colder, later into the spring. Do you get many late frosts, or usually have a pretty clean transition?
Have considered Zestar before (and think I may have a couple grafts), and will have a look at Wealthy, Mantet, and State Fair… I don’t think I’ve looked at those previously. At a minimum, if you’ve had good luck with them and they have good reports on flavor or use, may try to get some scion wood and do some grafts this year.
On Honeycrisp, while I know a lot of folks here aren’t keen on them, we like them. I planted one about 11 years ago, and moved away maybe 7 years ago. It produced and set well the year before we left, and the flavors were way better than the ones you find in the grocery… and my daughter loves those, so still an option, but ours did get hit by fireblight that almost girdled it at year 3 or so. I think I shaved down the central leader to maybe a 4 or 5 mm wide swath of cambium remaining, but the tree is still there, so guessing it recovered ok… at least it looked like it was originally (pic, below). However, I’ve also heard they can go biennial, and I’m not clear how that impacts grafted varieties. Anyone know?
On root stocks, I should have looked deeper into my notes, as I had already gathered some information from you, a few others here, and some other sources. However, Antonovka is a new addition to the list. Who are you finding is selling trees on that rootstock? I haven’t seen it much.
On the rootstock topic, and sharing some general information with others: I did talk with the guy who used to own the U-pick operation at Masonville orchards, and he seemed to indicate that Bud 118, M111, and M7 all do well here. That said, I am pretty sure they spray in their orchard. Interesting is that USU Extension says “In apple orchards, not all rootstocks are equally prone to sucker. We recommend avoiding planting apple trees on M.7 rootstocks.” However, I’d think suckering is a lesser concern than our concerns of fireblight and powdery mildew.