I’ve been growing and planting my own onion seed for 3 or four years now (with an additional planting of new commercial OP seed as well) and just harvested this year’s “crop”. Noticed something different this year. The replanted onions grew great and flowered, however most of the flowerettes did not produce seed, maybe around 10%. One other odd thing is most of these flower heads also produced tiny onions, like an egyptian or walking onion.
I am curious if there are any other onion seed growers out there, and if anyone knows what might cause an onion to favor “sets” vs seed.
I will plant the “sets” just to see what they produce, but it seems a bit odd.
Curious how many onions did you plant for seed? I’m planning to do this next year and some sources say only 3 are needed but The Manual of Seed Saving recommends 15-20 onions to supply sufficient genetics (?) for strong seed.
Also curious if you had other allium varieties flowering at the same time since alliums are outcrossers.
I generally plant 3-4 onions (the best of the previous year’s crop). I don’t believe there are any wild or other alliums nearby, this is a pretty harsh climate and wild onion is not native AFAIK; And these seed onions are grown second year in the greenhouse (because our season is short enough that seed may not mature outside), so very unlikely they got any “wild pollen”.)
Good thoughts, but I was thinking it might have been something in how I grew them out that caused this, but too small a genetic pool might be an issue.
Hi Steve, I’ve been growing my own seed since 1995 from whatever early op varieties that were available back then so I have a mix, though now my line is likely narrower since I’ve been selecting what I like best over those years. I grow them outside but do have trouble getting a good crop of seed with the short season some years, which is dicey since the seed doesn’t last only 2-3 years. I plant them in the fall, 6-8 of the best bulbs, mulched well. I did once have them both flower and set bubils, back in 2001. I think that was the only time and my notes just state my surprise and that it was a good seed year anyway. I doubt that I did anything different than usual. I didn’t plant the bulbils but now wish I had. It’ll be interesting to see how yours grow. Since the seed planted from that year was true to type following years it most likely wasn’t due to crossing with something else (as with yours, I didn’t have anything for it to cross with anyway). I don’t know the scientific reason but it’s the kind of thing that keeps me saving my own seed all these decades. Sometimes nature gives you a fun surprise! Sue
Thought I would update on the results of the sets/bulbils experiment.
I planted about 1/3 of a bed with the bulbils. This was both to see how they would do as well as to help out with my onion harvest since the seed grown onions did poorly this year. Now that all the onions are out of the ground and in the barn curing, I can pass on my observations:
The plants from the bulbils/sets did great. There grew much more strongly than the seed planted onions did this year. Both inside at the start as well as after xplanting outside. The onions they produced were generally larger than the seed-grown ones. Too early to say much about keeping quality or taste just yet. One downside is the they also sent up flower stalks at about 5x the rate as the seed grown onions (same growing environment, etc). Still wasn’t that bad, <10% but way more than I see on the seed grown ones of the same variety. So depending on how well they store and taste, I’d say growing onions from bulbils seems to be a good alternative.
One other observation, the onion flowers that produced these bulbils also made some seed. That seed had very poor germination, and the onions which did germinate did not grow very well. (I also planted seed from previous years and some commercial, and none did well this year, but the bulbils flower ones did worst.) Not sure what that means, if anything.
One thing I would likely try if I see another onion flower that is producing bulbils, is to selectively pick out either the flowers or the bulbils, and see what results that gives. The people who developed true garlic seed use this technique (you pick out the immature bulbils and garlic can/will produce flowers which make true seed). If this opportunity presents itself, it will be interesting to see if the seed and bulbils carry similar characteristics. However with onion bulbils, it is an opportunity to develop a true genetic clone variety.