Hi Y’all from NE Tennessee! Glad to find a knowledgeable community of fruit tree growers! I’m looking at getting a couple apple trees for my backyard. I’m in a bit of a quandary with where to place them and what kind of rootstocks to use/get. My yard gets ample sun but it’s oriented West to East with the backyard facing East. I’ve put my vegetable garden in the northeast corner because that’s the flattest spot in the yard (the yard also slopes east) and it does really well there. I’ve been looking at getting trees from Century Farm Orchard but he only offers trees on M111 and Bud9. I don’t want to get something that will be gigantic and shade the garden but I’ve heard that Bud9 doesn’t do as well with clay soil and has other issues. I just got Ann Ralph’s book on Growing a Little Fruit Tree but I’m not sure those methods will work on apple trees on M111 in East TN (zone 7b). Any advice?
My 2 cents, growing both dwarf and semi-dwarf trees. A home gardener can get all the dessert apples he/she needs on a dwarf tree. I have gotten phenomenal results from dwarf trees grown as small bushes. 15 gallons is typical. Some people say that apples on dwarf trees don’t taste as good, but if true I’ll bet t’s because the grower lets the tree overbear. So one recommendation would be to thin the fruit. Also the roots of a dwarf tree don’t penetrate as deep, so they should be well staked.
That said, it’s not too difficult to keep a tree on MM.111 or Bud9 under 15’. A tree that height won’t cast much shade. You would need a ladder both for picking and pruning, whereas all work on a dwarf can be done from the ground.
Greetings and welcome. We have some great posters from Tennessee who will chime in too I hope. M111 can be held to 12 feet with constant pruning. A lot of work. A good pair of mid size candidates are Geneva 969 and 890.
G.969 has a weak graft reputation. But that is with bark/bud grafts. Not whip and tongue and cleft grafts.
Lastly I encourage you to investigate your state’s fine historic varieties. Black Limbertwig. Blacktwig {Rankin Toole’s}, Fugate and others.
Dwarf trees are don’t seem to be terribly productive in the south but are not a bad choice either. I would probably roll the dice with a G41 for dwarf trees.
If you have severe deer pressure, it may make sense to grow an M111 and graft about 10 varieties to it.
If you do plant an M111, it must be very blight resistant because in 15 years, you won’t be able to access parts of the tree to prune it out.
FWiW, I have two B9s in clay soil. Mulch helps keep it from turning into brick.
Make sure you don’t plant too many TN heritage trees or trees listed as many have ineffective/sterile pollens or are triploid. I’m always in a jam with pollination because nearly all the trees I’m interested in are triploid. This includes old world apples and local heritage apples.
Black Twig
Ark Black
Possibly Black Limbertwig
Stayman
Winesap
Myers Royal Limbertwig
Turley Winesap
I’m suspicious about the Swiss Limbertwig as well.
Thank y’all! How about Grimes Golden?
Welcome to the forum, glad to have more representation from NE TN ![]()
I started out grafting and growing trees on M111 only to change course towards smaller trees and removing/replacing those earlier ones.
Every area is different but if we do happen to be relatively close.. FYI the biggest pests I’ve dealt with have been Deer(!), fungal, plum curculio, wooly apple aphid.
FWIW “MyFruitTree” has DNA sequenced Grimes Golden and appear to indicate that it’s diploid. It should therefore be able to pollenize other trees. It’s a parent of Golden Delicious and is also fairly highly regarded.
![]()
Thank you! What other varieties have you tried? I’m leaning towards Century Farms Orchard mainly because of cost and their passion for old Southern apples (a fascinating subject btw!). I’m trying to find varieties that won’t require a lot of spraying or at least using chemicals. I’ve looked at Evergreen in Johnson City but they don’t have a lot of options.
I’ve never grown a yellow or green apple that did not see Cedar Apple Rust. While this affliction is not generally life threatening to the tree, secondary issues follow CAR such as Marssonina Apple Blotch which can defoliate a whole tree along with Bitter Rot.
If you want to grow strictly organic, your options are few. With a few well-timed interventions, the options are much better. Immunox and Captan are fungicides that are not organic but are likely not harmful either. Immunox is for the CAR and Captan is for the late Summer rots. I’m using Kaolin for insecticide. Copper dormant spray is must as well.
The problem with many old varieties is the lack of well documented notes on disease resistance. Curators generally gloss over this stuff because they’re sorta fancy themselves as curators, not nurseries. One good example is the Carolina Red June. I love this little apple but keeping the damn thing alive is a challenge due to fire blight. Some for the Williams Favorite, Spitz, Newtown Pippin.
I would try some new varieties along with the old. Novamac, Rubyrush, Williams Pride, are generally regarding as blight resistant and are not so prone to rots. If you don’t mind spraying some, the Goldrush should be given consideration. The Golden D epitomizes everything that sucks about apple growing in the south.
The Mammoth Black Twig the Century Farms is selling may be worth having. It apparently tastes nearly the same as an old strain of Stayman that I used to grow that is far superior to many of the fruit stand strains. It is also better imo than the Major Rankin Toole’s Black Twig.
I haven’t grown a Kinnairds Choice, but it’s very similar in flavor and appearance as the King David. I would rate the flavor as a 6 out of 10.
The Victoria Limbertwig is the most disease resistant tree that I grow. Very generic flavor but well above average texture.
There are many apples I’d like to try, but fear growing them due to the risk of blight. These are the American Summer Pearmain, Horse, Hollow Log, Golden Russett, Seek-no-Further and there are a bunch of triploids such as the Blenheim Orange, Roxbury Russet, Reinette Zabergau, and many others.
Welcome @BirdDawg89 to the forum, its a great place to be. We have several knowledgeable members in Tennessee.
Yes I’ve definitely concerned about CAR as I have at least one cedar tree within a stone’s throw of my lot. Initially I was drawn to Freedom and Liberty due to their disease resistance but wasn’t sure about how they were on flavor. I’m definitely drawn to some of the hardier heirlooms, especially the Lumbertwigs. Mr Vernon of Century Farms Orchard recommended Grimes Golden, Kinnairds Choice, and Summer Banana. I’ll see if he has those on B9. Also, have most of y’all planted on slopes or flatter ground? About the only place I can plant a couple trees is down in a low spot in my yard.
The Freedom apple is not as disease resistant in the south as it should be. Both are meh. Liberty is overrated imo as well.
If you’re going to buy modern varieties,
Early ripening choices are Williams Pride and Pristine. Pristine reportedly tastes better. Williams Pride is a more disease resistant.
The Novamac receives great reviews from a grower in central TN
Next is Rubyrush
A good late season variety is the Sundance. This apple is very highly rated for disease resistance by the University of Kentucky and regarded highly by some here.
The search feature on this site works well. Search these names on this site.
Hah! Williams Pride got spit up and chewed out by fireblight 3 tries here…lol
I am growing pristine (no apples yet) it was planted this year. Even with synthetic fungicide (not sprayed as much as I normally would, because non-bearing) the foliage is not looking good.
It was looking okay until we had some excessive humidity. I think the lighter color apples tend to suffer a bit more from the defoliating stuff- but maybe it’s just the varieties I have.
The limbertwig’s foliage is looking great. So you might be onto something there.
Of those disease resistant apples, I’m a bit of a wierdo and actually like enterprise. I think they have good flavor and I don’t mind the thick skin. Enterprise does well with minimal spraying.
I do think trying to grow fruit in the humid south (especially near cedar trees) with zero synthetic fungicides might be a loosing battle. I don’t want @BirdDawg89 or others to be too disappointed if they do have to spray a bit. I can get away with minimal spraying on apples in good years if I use a synthetic 2-3 times- it’s not too bad having to do that.
Re: rootstock and growing in a low spot in TN - is @TNHunter growing any apples? I think his place is in a valley.
Either way, if you use dwarf rootstock (or while your larger rootstock trees are young) be sure to protect from deer, rabbits, voles, etc. I just have cages around individual trees.
Northeast TN has a lot of sloped ground, including mine ![]()
As others have indicated, growing fruit trees here as either “no spray” or “organic” can be challenging.
Many apple cultivars will grow just fine in this area, I have 50+ primarily heirloom varieties. Many have had fireblight strikes, I keep a close watch and cut them out as soon as I spot 'em. Myclobutanil has been very effective at preventing CAR. Wet year this year so my fruit had a lot of summer rot problems though.
Finding the varieties you want, on the rootstock of your choice.. Can be even more challenging. If you have an interest in grafting, most local county extension offices offer classes in the spring.
Good luck.
Grafting is fun! Apples are easy!
I learned how to graft just from reading stuff on this site. For a couple years, I used a box cutter and electrical tape. You can order scions and some rootstock for less than a tree. However, it does take a year or two for them to get as big as a tree you’d buy.
You can also just buy a couple trees of something you can find on a good rootstock, then graft additional varieties on later.
Spraying for fireblight is not as bad as it is billed as. It is a vast help for young grafts which have no resistance built up. And during blooming. Even with a 100 or so trees it does not take long. Once the trees get 4-5 years old; trimming strikes works.
I am actually on a ridge top.. around 900 ft elevation in southern middle TN.
I have two apples in my orchard on M7 rootstock… which is supposed to help with fireblight resistance.
Two varieties.. Early Mcintosh and Novamac.
I have Cedars all over.. but those two are hardly affected at all by CAR. You might see a red spot on a few leaves now and then.. but it does not affect the growth or vigor..
I tried growing a gold rush here… And it got CAR something awefull… and died in year 4 of fireblight.
I have one Novamac on B9 growing in a half whisky barrel container… trained espellar.
I have grafts of Trailman, Pristine, Enterprise and Chestnut added to my (3 trees). Going to add a graft or two of Rubyrush next spring.
I have eaten trailman and pristine apples from those so far and they were very good.
Novamac is rated very high on resistance to Fire Blight by Perdue. Mine has gotten FB a few times but I have been able to prune it out and it keeps coming back strong.
Early Mac is a cross of Mcintosh/Yellow Transparent… and is in flowering group 2. Here most of the time it blooms and sets fruit before it gets warm enough for fireblight. When it does get fireblight.. it is on those few late blossoms on the limb tips and it does not spread much at all… Easy enough to prune out.
PS… I grow Organic. My trees have never been sprayed. I do hang a coddling moth trap on each scaffold branch that is bearing fruit. This has been working well for me for about 3 years now.
I have to get the traps baited (50/50 mix of molasses and water) and hung in the tree as soon as fruits start setting.
TNHunter
Brittle grafts on G-969 seem to be dependent on apple variety and type of graft. I have trees on 969 that were chip budded and survived nasty wind storms with only a 1/4" diameter bamboo stake as support. This is their 3rd leaf in ground and the rootstock is ~2" in diameter. I also have one tree on G-890 and another on order. They are the only 2 apple rootstocks I order now because they are disease resistant, tolerant of clay soil, free-standing, and dwarfing enough to easily manage in a home orchard. I prefer G-969, but I am using G-890 when there are compatibility issues or a lower vigor scion.
PS…I am now wondering if I can festoon my apple trees with small codling moth traps to promote spurring at the same time. Codling moth has not found my trees yet, but it is a matter of time.
Thank you for the great tips!
