Mostly finished harvesting, flavor reports from my orchard

This year was a bumper crop. No late frosts like at least 2 of the past 5 years. I had some real suprises and some real duds. I will try to list this in ripening order.

  1. Monark. Usually I enjoy these mostly because they are the first to ripen. They are good for an early season apple. Nice texture and balance but no complexity. This year though my friend made most of them into sauce which was unbelievable. Somehow complex flavors came out in the sauce. I tend not to process much and have focused my efforts on fresh eating dessert apples. My strategy has been to make friends with people who do like to process. I’m not kidding, the sauce was unreal. She likes to process sauce very smooth using a stick blender. Everyone else also thought it was awesome. Usually I don’t pay that much attention to this tree but from now on I will prune for maximum productivity, pick up and wash drops etc. She wants me to grow a second one.
  2. Snow. I’m starting to get tired of this one. I still like it better than it’s parent (I think) Mcintosh. It’s just kind of one dimensional. I may keep it around because it’s a heavy producer and I’m thinking of buying a cider press next year
  3. Cox. Somewhat disappointing this year. Texture and flavor where good, nice and balanced but little richness and complexity. Cox seems to be like this at least every other year. Might not be worth growing for most of us. Seems to bear every other year, flavor is only great every other year that it bears and it’s the most scab prune variety here. I’ll keep it but if I knew this I probably wouldn’t have grown it to begin with
  4. Rubinette. Same as cox this year. Balanced flavor but no complexity or richness. Much easier to grow than cox, bears well every year and much less fungus
  5. Eden. This has been the star of the show. This is the first time I have had a large crop that wasn’t taken by raccoons or squirrels. This was by far my families favorite and we are eating them like crazy. Very rich and nutty flavor. Hints of malted barley or unfermented beer (wort) High sugars and plenty of acid. These are probably half the size of a standard apple but about 50% bigger than wickson. We think they taste like lychee, my neighbor says they taste like a smoothie made with lychee and kiwi. Unreal this year.
  6. Hudson’s Golden Gem. Also a star in my orchard. Very sweet with little sour but the sweetness is rich and complex. Honeyed an pear like. Very nice texture, slightly dry. These always get a little watercore but it’s one of those varieties that actually taste better with watercore. I like them so much I planted another one last year and just planted a 3rd this fall.
  7. Nonesuch. Not great. Wasn’t quite sure when to pick them so I sample them every 3-4 days for about 3 weeks. The never developed the perfumed scent of flavor that they are known for. I planted it because an orchard down the road grows it and I enjoyed them.
  8. Tollman sweet. We always love these. Very sweet with no sour. A little banana like flavor. It wasn’t a great year because of san jose scale.
  9. Razor Russet. Not great this year and a similar flavor and texture profile to Hudson’s Golden Gem and similar season. HGG is much better and I would rather eat them. I will give RR another season.
    Rubaiyat. Better year this year. Ripened and colored up inside before going mushy. These are a little too sour. I probably wouldn’t grow it again but friends like the novelty when I give them some.
  10. Kidd’s Orange Redd. Disappointing. No complex flavor and tested like a good golden delicious. This was the first good crop though so hopefully better in years to come.
  11. Karmijn de Sonneville. I only got about 5 apples from this tree but they are unbelievable. So far all the apples I have every tasted these are the most intense. When you bite into one it’s like Wham! I think it might be too much for some people.
  12. Drippin honey pear. These were fantastic.
14 Likes

Hi! What Eden is yours? It’s Eden Crab ™ (CV. Etter 30-32) or it’s the new dual purpose apple Eden TM?

2 Likes

When did the Eden ripen for you?

2 Likes

Etters Eden Crab

2 Likes

Eden ripened mid October for me here in zone 6a

1 Like

Thanks! Thats what i thought… this is a variety that i didn’t know but now i desire… :grin:

2 Likes

I have tried a lot of apples. I have about 25 bearing varieties and Alber orchard is right down the road from me and they have about 120. I have also order a lot of different varieties over the internet. Etters Eden is now my all time favorite and my wife’s too.
It’s funny about half of our friends find it to be really bad. I guess some people just dont have a refined palette.

3 Likes

Most people favor straight sweet apples. The acid is to much for them. Are you doing any trades this year?

1 Like

Not sure what I might need. Won’t decide until later.
I will ship you some sticks no charge though.
I am disorganized so you will have to remind me in the winter. I’ll cut some and send right away

1 Like

Thanks for the report! Good to hear that Eden is doing well. I got a bunch of varieties from Greenmantle many years ago but the plants were super wimpy and died and never tried them again. Sounds like I may want to try Eden one of these years.

Re: Nonsuch, it needs to be picked late and they don’t ripen much more off the tree. They redden up far too early which makes it misleading on when to pick. I would wait several weeks longer next year. They were always aromatic for me every year. Some years they are better than others though.

Re: Kidds it is indeed in the Golden Delicious school, but Golden Delicious if grown well is an excellent apple with tons of flavor; it sounds like you might just not like that kind of apple. Kidds is a bit less cloying in the aromatics to me compared to GD so I like it a bit more.

Hi Scott,
Thanks for that info. I am sure I picked them too early. I only had about 20 apples on the tree and I was sampling them every few days once they colored up. I probably picked the last one before they were ripe. Hopefully they will be better next year.
Alber Orchard is about 8 miles down the road from me and I have had great nonesuch from them. However, it seems they have a bit different microclimate than I do. They seem to be at least a week ahead of me with everything.
I will put it in my notes to pick them later next year.