Peach variety report after winter 2024/2025

In case anyone’s interested, thought I’d do a quick report of peach varieties which had the best and worst bloom after a pretty tough winter.

We had two nights this winter where it got pretty cold at the orchard. One in January, where it got down to about -9F at the orchard. Not good, but there was a worse night in Feb 2025 where it got down to about -11/-12ish. Underground weather personal weather stations were reporting anything from about -13F to a low to -10F in locations close to the orchard.

The orchard itself is on a hill. So the upper part is warmer than the lower part.

I won’t mention all the varieties we have in the ground, just the ones more notable for this list. These are the ones which had the most bloom, starting with the best (in rough order).

Encore - Pretty much a full bloom

Contender - About like Encore. Maybe a few less flowers than Encore.

Ernies Choice - Pretty decent bloom.

Redhaven - Less bloom than Ernies choice, but still enough for a full crop at this point in the spring.

Harrow Diamond - About like Redhaven in bloom survival.

JulyPrince - This one surprised me. Many times JulyPrince has gotten all it’s blooms knocked out in a bad winter. But this year trees have some blooms. Not enough for a full crops, but much better than many others.

Madison - Maybe a tad less flowers than JulyPrince.

Earlystar - The ones higher up on the hill had a lot of blooms. The ones lower down did just OK.

Intrepid - Noticeable bloom.

Baby Crawford - Not anything close to a lot of blooms, but some blooms.

Victoria - Normally Victoria is pretty winter tender, but this year it had some blooms while many other trees had nothing.

Carolina Gold - Like most trees this far down on the list, Carolina Gold had a thin bloom but some blooms.

Following are some of the worst blooming varieties:

Blazingstar -Trees have nothing. Not surprising. Blazingstar is a spectacular tasting peach, but it gets wiped out easily in cold winters. This year was not exception.

Allstar - Like Blazingstar, Allstar doesn’t like cold winters. However Allstar isn’t the greatest tasting peach. It needs to be replaced in my orchard.

Loring - Known for being winter tender, it’s blank this year. Needs removed.

Glenglo - Like it’s cousin Loring, it’s also winter tender. Trees are pretty much blank. It’s a very large good tasting early peach, but just not productive enough to keep.

PF 14 - Have just one tree of this variety. It’s never productive. This year it’s blank. It’s a loser here.

Redskin - Pretty much blank this year.

Laurol - Some blooms, just not very many. This can be a very productive variety. I have nothing better or this harvest window.

Winblo - Pretty disappointing because many times it will produce fruit after a hard winter. This year very very sparse blooms.

PF19-007 - Few blooms. Contender ripens in the same window and is vastly more productive, even if the quality of Contender isn’t quite as good.

Veteran - Few blooms. It’s had some problems in other bad winters too.

PF35-007 - Another surprise how poor and non-existent the bloom is on these trees. In the past they had done really well and very productive in all but the roughest winters. They did very poorly this winter.

Challenger - I had hoped this would be the variety for me in the week that follows Redhaven harvest. But this year a whole row of Challengers had few blooms.

There are several varieties which didn’t make the best or worst list. Overall very disappointing bloom this year. If we get any rough spring weather, it will knock out any potential fruit which survived the winter, which I would expect, given how early it is in the Spring.

26 Likes

Another tough winter. I’m sorry to hear that. I hope spring treats you much better.

Nice report as always. Maybe I need Blazingstar in my greenhouse. I think I had it just outside the GH at one point. But can’t remember what they tasted like or maybe I never got any fruit.

If you don’t mind me asking, what are the best tasting peaches you’ve ever grown if eating quality were the only consideration?

3 Likes

Thanks for your report @Olpea! I enjoy comparing. I had similar temps this winter and some of the same results. My July Prince and Encore trees have lots of blossoms. Challenger trees had very few blossoms. I had high hopes for them as well. Surprising that Veteran did poorly for you. They are loaded for me and are one of my most consistent performers. Let’s hope temperatures will cooperate this spring. 10 day forecast looks good.

5 Likes

You all are far ahead of me. We had our first 70 degree day today. I had an Iowa Hardy apricot graft bloom today, Zard and Jerseycot are in popcorn stage, but my peaches aren’t showing much of anything yet. Hopefully that continues for a few more weeks.

1 Like

Boy that is cold Olpea! Xxoo Mrsg

1 Like

I think Blazingstar would be near the top. Other notable peaches would be Ernies Choice (in a dry year) and a mislabled peach we call Tubby Dubby.

For a white peach probably what I call Spring Snow (though I’m not sure if that’s the variety or not) would be the best.

3 Likes

Supposed to get down to 34 in the KC area tonight. Sometimes we get 3 or 4 degrees colder where my orchard is. We do have a lot of spring left (for blooms to get frozen off).

1 Like

In the Colorado Front Range thread I noted a very early spring for us as well. Do you mind if I ask how ahead of schedule your peaches are compared to a typical spring?

2 Likes

I started recording first bloom of peaches in 2006. Two years I didn’t record because the peaches experienced 100% winter bud kill. The earliest first bloom was March 6th in all those years. The latest bloom was April 15th.

The average was March 28th.

The first bloom on any peach tree this year was March 24th.

7 Likes

Ok, so not too early compared to normal. Best wishes for a frost-free spring for you!

3 Likes

Hi Mark!
It’s insane how much location matters.
My orchard’s in zone 6a…I haven’t even had a first bloom yet and probably won’t until April 12th, or later, we actually got winter this year, that’ll push flowering later.

4 Likes

BentonPeach… I am just down the road from you and my peaches should pop in another day or two. I was happy to squeeze in a dormant spray yesterday!

2 Likes

I have 4 peaches, 3 of them are huge, and I’ve seen very few blooms on them. It was a long, very cold winter here, a couple nights below zero in January.

And the two largest trees are Contender and Blushingstar, which are supposedly more winter hardy. Maybe it’s because they haven’t been properly pruned over the last several years and have gotten way too tall, like over 15 ft high. They’re about 18ft apart and their limbs are touching each other. Probably not enough new wood on them.

My other fruit trees, however, pears, apples, plums, pluots, are loaded with fruit buds and blooms this year.

As of 3/23 this it what my trees looked like



Wrapped up snug as a bug.
Granted that was a week ago.
But normally (and this is actually sort of normal because we got a winter) I’m looking at the end of the 2nd week of April for bloom.

3 Likes

Despite ~15 miles between us, I am classified as a 6b, as I am close to the Susquehanna River. I just looked back at the one year that I recorded bloom times and I have April 1 for Glengo and Red Haven and April 5 for Ernie’s Choice and Contender. I am going to be pretty close to those dates again this year.

2 Likes

Bummer to hear about that. I missed reading your peach report last fall too! Unfortunately i have confirmed huge losses this year as well. Here’s my estimated count.

4 year old peach trees

Belle of georgia 40-60 blooms
Contender 20+ blooms
Red haven 20+ blooms
White Lady 5
Contender mislabel? 5
Sure crop 0

3 year old peach trees

Earlystar 0
Blushinstar 0
Autumnstar 0
Desiree 0
Victoria 0
Tiana 0

Pear trees are loaded but may get hammered in next week’s 25 degree forecast.

Apples are just breaking cluster tips. Hoping they stay tight for a bit longer.

Sometimes this is so frustrating.

2 Likes

I don’t like hearing that about Challenger. I just got one of those a month ago.

2 Likes

I’m always surprised how early things bloom in Kansas … I think my first peach blossom or two showed up just today and most of them have a week or so to go. I’m originally from the more northern midwest, that probably skews my impressions.

2 Likes

Same here. I just planted a Challenger last spring from Cummins. It looks fantastic. No flowers, but I didn’t think anything of it being so young. Now wondering if I’ll be yanking it for an intrepid or contender in a few years.

6 trees arriving from Cummins tomorrow. Going in ground right away. 2 are peaches. Intrepid and a PF-24C. I need cold hardy and frost tolerant peach trees.

1 Like