Note: Those of you on the western and southern edges of this region may find a need to create a separate group, but for now I am including you! I just feel like the arid and subtropical climates may feel more “at home” in a separate discussion group as you will face different challenges from the rest of us. We’re a big and sparse region though, so I understand if we end up coming here to discuss.
States
Colorado, Iowa, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, Illinois, Nebraska, North Dakota, South Dakota, Wisconsin, and Wyoming.
Oh! I guess we can include you. I thought Illinois might be more at home in a group with Indiana, Ohio, etc? The Midwest is such a tricky region because it can get huge fast.
Edit: Should I maybe do a map based on hardiness zone and Köppen classification? That way folks in the arid and subtropical parts of this region know they may want to group up separately for the most relevant discussion? I’m just thinking of the PNW & Willamette Valley groups as an example.
Michigan is hard, too. The northern part (and especially the Upper Penninsula) should be with Minnesota and Wisconsin, but the southwest and southeast would be more at home with Indiana and Illinois or even Ohio (I live 45 minutes from Ohio). Maybe we need to narrow by zones or at least include those with our state. I’m in SE Michigan, Zone 6a.
I agree, Michigan seemed a bit of a gamble. See my edit on my post above? I probably won’t have time to make a map until this weekend but maybe that would help us.
As I understand it, anyone can read any post, so all are free to pick and choose the group most relevant. For example, I never read the citrus, fig, jujube, goumi, persimmon, pluot, paw paw, almond, or tropical fruit posts. No point in it.
@smsmith I’m in Saint Paul, MN. USDA says we are still in Zone 4b, but almost every year I’ve lived up here (8 years now) I’ve had rosemary, lavender, and oregano overwinter successfully. This leads me to think the urban heat island and sheltered microclimate are bringing my area closer to a Zone 5.
I grew up in eastern SD and may still share posts from that area when I visit. Everything just seems colder, windier, drier, and more vulnerable back home. That’s my standard for a Zone 4 mentally, although I know that’s probably not the “right” way to think about it.
Is Colorado not considered midwest? I always thought were were because people used to think we were all cowboys and cowgirls. I guess now we are known for being stoners but that used to not be the case. Also I feel like our climate is much harder to grow in with Colorado than Wisconsin or Iowa. The Dakota states and Wyoming are just freezing cold. There is a reason no one wants to live in Wyoming even though it is cheap as heck living there. I feel our cold dry winds are bad and it is even worse in Wyoming.
I did not understand the concept of “winter wonderland” until I moved to Minnesota! I think the closest SD winters came was when you had that rare foggy night that turned into hoarfrost by morning. Minnesota and Wisconsin also have so much more vegetation, which adds texture and colour in winter. It’s very beautiful here. In eastern SD it is just a lot of grey and brown. The snow either gets honed into crust or scattered into dust.
I also went to SDSU - sadly, I think the N.E. Hansen research farm was sold to the Babybel factory. All those old, neglected apple trees are probably gone… who knows what they were.
The Cities are the banana belt of MN. Get down towards Owatonna and it’s colder than the Cities (and much more windy). I’m about 2 hours NW of the Cities. Just under 2 hours to Fargo. Very different climate than the Cities.
