My new list
Disease resistant pears
1.Clarks small yellow pear -10
2.warren-8
3.drippin honey -8
4.potomac -7
5. Korean giant -8
6. Ayers -7
7.karls favorite -7
8. Seckle-6
9. tyson? -8
10. Leona -5
Pears im undecided on or have not had with
some disease resistant.
Bell
Ambrosia
Gem
Beurre Bon louise d’ Avr
Honeysweet
Purdue
Harrow crisp
Tyson
Conference
Luscios
Green jade
My old list
Many of you know a great pear when you taste it. This is my list of recommendations. Flavor rated 1-10 is what it’s capable of. Keep in mind i have not tried every pear. Lets add to this list.
Disease resistant pears
1.Clarks small yellow pear -10
2.harrow sweet -8
3.drippin honey -8
4.harrow delight -7
5. Korean giant -8
6. Ayers -7
7. Clara frijs-7
8. Seckle-6
9. Warren -7
10. Karls favorite-5
Non disease resistant
Bosc 8
Clapps favorite 8
Doyenne Comice 7
Bartlett 6
Abbe fetel 5
Magness 7
D’anjou 6
Forelle 3-7 variable
Chojuro 8
Hosui 6
Pears to try im undecided on or have not had
Potomac
Fondante de moullin lille
Docteur desportes
Citron de carmes
Honeysweet
Concorde
Paragon
Beurre superfin
Aurora
Luscious
Harvest queen
White doyenne
Dana hovey
Tyson
What do you think about Hood, @clarkinks? It seems like it should at least rate the undecided list, given its disease resistance. Or is the bloom too early?
Since Potomac made the new list… it had been awhile since anyone expanded on this but you said it tastes like a very good Anjou. Looking forward to mine bearing in the next years.
He collected scions this year but i dont think he’s to a point of being able to sell them yet. I also gave him ayer not ayers and estella. He has had ayers for years. Ayer, estella, and douglas are grown by the ayer family in Douglas county kansas in the 1800’s. Hood is reportedly very good at most sites. @39thparallel left a little bit ago. Was showing him my next remote orchard site.
The problem is it is very inconsistent in production. Like a wild strawberry it is delicious but still more wild than tame. They dont store or ship but when they are on they are the best i ever tasted. Once you tasted them at their best nothing else will match them. Like a wild strawberry they can try to match the flavor but they cant.
I wish i knew what would do it. I use aged cow manure on it to try to deliver a steady fertilizer. Fireblight isnt an issue. I dont know about chill hours etc. On this one yet.
I have limited Pear experience. Ayer’s is in year 2 here. There are a couple of Bartlett’s and a bit of leaf curl is the only thing I’ve seen on them. But we do not mess with them anyway. They are on the swamp line and critters keep fruit off of them.
Buerre d’Amalis (as sold by Fedco) is large and high quality mid season pear. I have seen some very large historic trees of the variety growing and producing untended, so it’s a hardy survivor and at least pest resistant. I grow Clara Frijs and really like that one. Dana Hovey is also a wonderful winter pear, great texture, flavor and sweetness.
Thank you for the updated list. My question is “what drove you to conclude that Warren and Magness were not only different pears, but pears with a significantly different level of disease resistance?”
I believe that I had read elsewhere that you supposed it possible that they are the same pear.
I aim to pair dutchess d angouleme at my moms with a scion of this Clark’s pair of yours. Sounds funny. There are pollinators like callery and my pears 1/2 mile away but wat something close.
Hope it’s somewhat of a vigor match. Would it do best grafted on north or south? It’s on ohf84.
Experience taught me they are totally different pears. They look the same both with leaves and fruit. They even taste the same. Once you grow them both you will know they are as different as different can be. Magness is more prone to fireblight and at my location takes longer to produce. When it does produce its a shy bearer. Your experience might be the opposite. Im going to add some karls favorites grafts on magness also. All that said warren is hard to pollinate but it blooms and thats the first step to success.
@AaronN I have it in the nursery for future scion production. @clarkinks has allowed me to collect scion for distribution by special request until I have it producing scion.
