In recent years I have waited to mention what scions are on the way. Too many times I have been all excited about planned or just-made grafts, only to find them knocked askew and dead, or sloppy work on my part and dead, or weather that challenges them until dead. You said, “confess…” In no particular order:
Blue Pearmain, Adams Pearmain, Duchess of Oldenburg, Benoni, Yellow Bellflower.
Derek Mills included Braddick Nonpareil in the lot he sent, which brings the possibility of another high-flavored apple to this region.
When the heirloom bug had me in its grip, I looked at Adams, until realizing it had poor working pollen. At that time I still wanted only 3 apple trees. Anything that acted like a triploid would restrict my options, so chose Claygate instead, which is triploid and better known. Claygate is the first apple I have tasted that compares well to Karmijn de Sonnaville: flavor that grabs you by the tonsils. KdS doesn’t do well in such dry and hot conditions as dominate my summers, so finding Claygate makes great fruit is a Godsend. (I have seen a grown man wince when biting into Claygate.)
While I forgot Adams, orangepippin.com had Adams tested, to learn it is diploid. Odd, since its female parts are resistant to frost and seem highly fertile, while the pollen is terribly weak. The stronger flavor it can produce interests me, so I hope to get it living on top one of my trees and on at least one other stock. to plant elsewhere.
Duchess of Oldenburg? Well, all anecdotes I have encountered to verify Nutting Bumpus as a seedling of D/O indicate they are genetically identical. That, to this layman’s mind, suggests NB is a bud sport, at best. So, with the range of temperatures in this area, If I can get D/O growing and producing, it will be much like NB in whatever conditions in New England made someone wonder if it differed from D/O. Good enough.
Perhaps I still have a case of heirloom lust, since Yellow Bellflower/Bellefleur dates to the first half of the 1700s and Blue Pearmain to the second half of that century. Benoni, targeting a young family I know that just might appreciate such an apple, is roughly 200 years in cultivation.