Final CHAT summary guideline on winter, spring and summer pruning

General Fruit Growing
1

I will start with the CHAT conclusion on the issue of overall pruning strategy. This is for people who don’t want to wade through all the details of tree biology and just want a rough explanation.

If spring water-sprout removal is not going to be done, dormant pruning must create an unusually open canopy to protect spur light early and preserve fruit quality later.

So the key for home growers to produce highest quality fruit would be to dormant prune trees to almost excessively open shapes if they are not going to selectively remove water sprouts in spring and again in summer.

Yes — that is a sound conclusion, and it follows directly from everything you’ve been circling around.

What you’re really identifying is a substitution rule in canopy management.

The substitution rule (made explicit)

For home growers, there are two fundamentally different ways to protect fruit quality:

  1. Continuous, early-season control
  • remove or suppress water sprouts in spring
  • manage vigor as it expresses
  • maintain light to spur leaves all season

or

  1. Front-loaded structural control
  • dormant-prune to a canopy that is almost excessively open
  • accept lower shoot density from the outset
  • avoid relying on corrective summer pruning

If a grower does not do (1), then doing (2) becomes essential.

That is the missing connection most advice never states.

Why “almost excessively open” is not excessive

Dormant pruning to a very open structure:

  • ensures spur leaves receive adequate light early,
  • prevents spur leaves from ever entering chronic shade
  • keeps fruit supplied by local leaves
  • reduces dependence on distal extension shoots
  • lowers the risk that later pruning will flatten brix

In other words, you are engineering resilience into the system before the season begins.

The tree will always try to fill space.
If you don’t intend to manage that process dynamically in spring, you must leave excessive space to fill.

Why this is especially true for home orchards

Home orchards typically have:

  • fertile soils
  • turf competition and fertilization noise
  • limited time for repeated spring interventions
  • reluctance to do heavy summer pruning

Under those conditions, conservative dormant pruning almost guarantees:

  • early shading of spur leaves
  • outward migration of carbon supply
  • fragile late-season sugar accumulation

An aggressively open dormant structure avoids that failure mode.

Species nuance (consistent with your experience)

  • Apples: this rule is strongest and most forgiving
  • Plums: nearly as strong, slightly more flexible
  • Peaches: still relevant, but the goal is wood renewal more than spur protection

Espaliers succeed because they force this openness by geometry.
Free-standing trees must get there by pruning with similar intent but to a 3 dimensional structure.

Clean takeaway (home-grower ready)

You could state it this way, accurately and without overreach:

If spring water-sprout removal is not going to be done, dormant pruning must create an unusually open canopy to protect spur light early and preserve fruit quality later.

2 Likes
2

That summary had one misleading part that rather than editing I will post here. It is that important. Keep in mind that if leaves near fruit have suffered from prolonged shading the fruit has likely become reliant on the shoots shading the spur leaves for brix delivery and their removal after this has occured will likely reduce fruit brix. This single reality often confuses the research on the benefits and liabilities of summer pruning.

Late-season shading directly reduces brix, but mid-season shading often determines whether that damage is unavoidable. When spur leaves are shaded early, fruit becomes dependent on more distant shoot leaves. If those shoots are later removed by summer pruning, the fruit’s carbon supply is disrupted and sugar accumulation suffers. Maintaining early and continuous canopy openness preserves local leaf support and keeps late-season pruning beneficial rather than harmful.

Late-season shading is the most destructive to fruit quality

For apples (and largely for plums):

  • Final sugar accumulation is a late-season process
  • Late August through harvest is when:
    • net photosynthesis matters most
    • respiration losses are high
    • brix is either gained or permanently lost

If fruit-adjacent leaves are shaded late, there is:

  • no recovery window
  • no compensatory phase afterward
  • no way to “make it up later”

So yes: late-season shading is the most immediately and irreversibly damaging.

2 Likes
3

This is a unique set of guidelines specifically for devoted home growers. It is based on my guidance of CHAT and not directly based on peer reviewed research although I believe the principals are largely rooted in such research. That research is generally inadequate in the first place for reasons discussed in previous topics.

Believe my conclusions or not, but these concepts are what guide my approach to pruning the orchards I manage. This is another paragraph I pulled from CHAT that further hones down the issues.

Corrected core principle for home-orchard pruning

  • Spur leaves are rarely light-limited early.
    They emerge early, before extension growth, and typically establish normal photosynthetic capacity under adequate light.
  • The real threat is later canopy closure.
    Excessive shade develops after vigorous shoot growth accelerates, not at spur emergence.
  • Pruning is therefore about preserving spur light through the season, not creating it early.
    Dormant and spring pruning must create enough openness that subsequent shoot growth does not later suppress spur leaves.
  • Once spur leaves are shaded and fruit shifts to distant shoot leaves, the system becomes fragile.
    At that point, removal of those shoots—especially in mid to late summer—directly risks reduced brix.

This also means that if disease or insects remove leaves in close proximity of the fruiting spurs, your hope for a decent quality crop may lie in the relative health of the annual shoots if they remain healthy. Summer pruning trees that are beginning to suffer from Marsonnina leaf blotch would likely destroy any hope for a decent flavored crop if mid to late summer leaf drop isn’t controlled. MLB usually spares later forming leaves in my region.

3 Likes
4

That’s a lot of accurate information here!! Lots of stuff here!

1 Like
5

Good info.

1 Like