Jelly of the Month Club

Chevy Chase’s Christmas Vacation is a cult classic in my family. One of the punchlines is that his Christmas bonus was a “1 year subscription to the Jelly of the Month Club.” Since I was making jelly this week, it got me thinking, with the stuff that I had growing, do I have enough fruit to make a different jelly each month? The answer was quickly no, because I don’t have that many fruits producing yet. But I thought it would be a fun thought experiment.
So if you were to make a “Jelly of the Month” club with whats ripening in your yard that month, which fruits would you choose?

With what I know I have enough of the make jelly, I would do Beautyberry in October, Roselle in November, and sour orange marmalade and jam in December.

6 Likes

I want Sour Cherry Jam/Fruit Spread 12 months a year…full stop.

I love blackberry, raspberry, black raspberry jam… also love me some Apple Butter and Strawberry preserves…

But to me nothing compares to Sour Cherry. I never get tired of it…and i will never not want it.

10 Likes

Late April to July… i make low sugar chia jam from strawberries, raspberries, loganberries, blueberries, blackberries, mulberries.

I have several half and 3/4 pints in the freezer now. When my daughter and granddaughter visit us… i remind her to take some home.

This fall… my wife made some pear preserves from euro pears we got from Englands Orchard. These are everyones favorite.

TNHunter

11 Likes

My hot pepper jelly.
Mom’s crab apple (from >30 years ago).
Mom’s elderberry/apple (from >30 years ago).

4 Likes

What do you eat hot pepper jelly on? I was thinking about a pepper jelly, but I always think of jelly for sweets, so it just didn’t seem right.

You can eat it like any jelly, but on cream cheese tames the heat. So crackers with cream cheese with jelly is a nice holiday snack.

4 Likes

oddly enough ive never made sour cherry preserves, I blend them into smoothies and ive made pies, next year Ill have to try that! Im thinking rhubarb/cherry sounds interesting, have you done that?

3 Likes

That is personal preference i would think… kind of like do you eat chili and/or slaw on your hot dog kind of thing.

There is no Black Raspberry jam or jelly here anywhere that i can find… no clue where it all goes. The stuff i make used to be my favorite but im a sour cherry addict now.

I have heard some folks talk about chokecherry jam/jelly… it sounds terrible but its probably really good.

This stuff is insanely good with chunks of cherries all thru it.

image

The possibilities are endless :crazy_face:

If you can get your hands on some for the holidays…it wont last long.

Amazon is chock full of them.

4 Likes

i got about 40lbs. sour cherries frozen in the freezer in the garage. i guess ill have to make some this winter. going to make black currant/ aronia, autumn berry, blueberry, blackberry, raspberry, black currant, gooseberry and honeyberry jam this winter. i usually make up a bunch this time of year to give out to family and friends for the holidays, then i make my jams to fill my pantry after the holidays. i like seeds and texture so i prefer jams instead.

7 Likes

Make a small batch for the holidays… u will be hooked.

I like how he pits them… insanely simple and easy to make.

5 Likes

mine are so soft when i harvest i just rip them open with my fingers to pit. goes really quick. i made a pie back in sept. with some but i don’t think it was for sour cherries as it wasn’t sweetened enough. il have to try another recipe next time.

6 Likes

I agree wholeheartedly! Sour cherry makes the best jelly; ties with elderberry in my book. No other fruit I have tried has that same flavor. It is so good that if I had the option between growing sweet vs. pie cherries it wouldn’t take me a second’s pause. Thankfully, I can get both!

3 Likes

Strawberry
Peach
Sour cherry
Gooseberry kiwi
Black current
Cornelian cherry
Rhubarb
Marion Berry
Apricot
Lingonberry
Mint
Jalapeno

I made it to 12!

Oops 13 forgot elderberry!

5 Likes

Some that I have had that I’d add would be persimmon, grape, rose, rosehip, fig, orange marmalade, raspberry, and chestnut. Easily takes you over 12!

1 Like

I haven’t had store bought jelly in over 4 years. Is is still a sugar bomb?

I mostly use them to make ice cream so maybe :joy:

A friend got me one of these a few years ago. Some of the flavors were great and inspired me to try some different variations with my own jam making. But the best two I make are a blueberry/nectarine jam and a tart plum jam made from satsuma. Very little sugar in both.

1 Like

Do you ever leave the pit in before freezing?

This is such a fun thread! I am really enjoying reading it and it has me thinking about attempting to do this next year.

Based on what I have available today, it would probably have to look like this for 2025:

Jan - apple
Feb - apple/mint
Mar - apple jalapeno
April - dandelion/rhubarb?
May - honeyberry
June - strawberry
July - cherry/blackberry
Aug - peach
Sept - strawberry/fig
Oct - strawberry/pawpaw
Nov - Asian pear
Dec - apple/bitter orange

3 Likes

yes i do.

1 Like

I thought there was a thing where you couldn’t heat pawpaw because it makes you sick? Does the jellying process not get hot enough to cause issues?

2 Likes