Sorry I didn’t respond sooner, I haven’t been on the forum for several weeks.
I think that taste is the most important thing in a pie! Visual appeal is nice and it’s fun to create food that looks good and draws you in. But if it doesn’t taste good, what’s the point?
Well… I guess the first thing that comes to mind is make sure your dough is not dry. When you add your liquid, the dough has to really stick together, it cannot be crumbly. This is a balancing act between wet enough, but not sticky. You need to add just enough, but not more than that.
I think it would help to have an extra piece of dough that you roll a bit thicker for the cutouts. That way the dough won’t rip and tear as easily when you try move and place the pieces on the pie. I don’t actually do that, but I think it would be a good idea!
It’s also helpful to have a smooth flat spatula or dough scraper to slide under the cut pieces to move them.
Sketch a rough design on paper and see if you can free hand draw what you want to create. Use a very thin sharp knife, maybe even an Exacto, to cut your designs, or use cookie cutters etc. to cut designs. I don’t have any pictures of my better flower/sunflower designs, but here’s a few of my very first ones I tried. I free-handed the cutouts and did a pretty bad job at making the shapes symmetrical, and the placement was not the best either. But it was fun and they tasted great. I’ve improved my technique since these pies.
A lot of the very fancy decorated pies you might see in pictures use a very thick dough specifically for it’s ability to be manipulated and cut intricately without tearing. I don’t have first-hand knowledge, but I surmise that those crusts do not impart a pleasant eating experience, and are for looks only. A thick dough is usually tough and/or chewy, which is not what we want in a pie crust! Some of the pictures I have seen are absolutely beautiful works of art! But I’m skeptical whether those crusts are edible.
So the number 1 priority for me is to make sure the pie and crust taste good! Crust should be light and flaky! And then pretty it up a bit if you can and want to.
Here’s a guide you might like to look through. Great pictures, descriptions, and recipes.
King Arthur Pie Baking Guide
I don’t even know what a calamondin is, so I’m looking that up! A dreamsicle pie- I definitely need to try that! That sounds amazing!!! Looks delish!!!
That sounds wonderful! I bet your family really enjoyed that! I actually prefer sour cherry pie with a streusel/oat topping, rather than a solid top crust. I think the brown sugar/oatmeal is just the perfect pairing for the tart cherries (I add bit of cinnamon to my streusel). My pie is kind of like a cobbler but with a pie crust shell. I do that a lot with apple and peach pie as well.