I’m growing that one too. Glad to see someone else has it. It will be several years before mine finally bears fruit. Sounds delicious!
2 Likes
I’ll try to ship it on Monday.
Miss your posts on the forum.
1 Like
A friend gave me 2 “Susquehanna” pawpaws. Judging from how firm the flesh was and how it tasted, these two were picked too early. Flesh was very firm and it hardly had any sweetness or any flavor to it. I could not finish them and threw the rest away.
I thought Susquehanna’s flesh is supposed to be yellow/orange. These two were whitish. I am not even sure they were the correct variety.
1 Like
I have a beginner pawpaw question! A friend of mine just offered me some seeds, and I figured why not, I’ll just stick them into the soil and hope I get a tree or two.
At this time of the year is it best to plant them outside or inside? This forum says they have a long fragile taproot and are slow to germinate. I only have spots for 2 trees (and more than 2 seeds), so I had originally planned on starting them indoors and planting out the strongest ones, but it sounds like they don’t take to transplanting or being moved very well. Also, I feel silly cold-stratifying in my fridge when our winters are 4 months long.
1 Like
The advantage to planting them indoors is that you can often have them start stratifying and germinating earlier. I’ve had some seeds in my fridge for over a month already that I plan on planting in containers in December to start germinating. They’ll hopefully be able to get a few months of growth before it gets warm enough and I can move them outside.
If time isn’t a major concern than planting them outside is a simpler option. Just bury them about an inch down and they should be fine and will begin germinating once it warms up again next year. You might plant more than two because you likely won’t have 100% success, but you can always dig up any extras that do develop.
Either option works, it’s just a matter of how you want to go about it.
5 Likes
One shall know a true ‘ripe for the picking’, Peterson ‘Queen Susquehanna’, by its Divinely flavored honey- caramel righteousness. Fruit of the Gods from the Tree of Life.
2 Likes
Looking good!
1 Like
Please let me know the results. 
1 Like
Excerpt from the Gospel of “Y”.
1 Like
Greetings frostcrystal. Your beginner Pawpaw question is a good, and thought provoking one, which brings to mind the awesome power of the directly sown pawpaw seed. It is likely that only a small percentage of your directly sown seeds would survive the freezing temperatures of a four month long winter. However, frostcrystal, the A. triloba tree successfully propagated itself by seed in northerly climes, long before the arrival of clever, crafty Bi-pedal Hominids with their zip lock baggies and electric refrigerators. Life finds a way. Age old wisdom dictates that the pawpaw seeds be firmly ensconced in opossum scat, (deer scat shall suffice, but 'possum scat is best), placed on their sides one inch down in soil amended with compost or decomposed cow manure with a final winter blanket of mulch. All efforts should be protected with wire cages, etc. Keep in mind next spring that the little Pawpaw seeds have enough naturally engineered Life-force to put down a foot-long taproot using zero photosynthesis. Be patient frostcrystal, and embrace the power and determination of the undisturbed, directly sown Pawpaw seed.
2 Likes
Ferver is a friend. West is the same as Cherimowest. @tonyOmahaz5 named it. central is a suspected Shen x Alleg cross. If you search this thread with “west”, “cherimowest,” or “central,” you’ll find taste descriptions from either myself or others.
1 Like
That reddish pinkish vein [to me] indicates partial spoilage. It was probably picked or fell off early. Sometimes the fruit will pull free even when not fully ripe if the tree is under heavy stress like excess or insufficient water. The color development looks interspersed between pale and yellow, so it could be a Susquehanna in a bad year.
1 Like
Both Susquehanna I got looked and felt underripe. It was almost tasteless.
Yesterday, I was given Overleese.
I think it was also underripe when picked. It was sweet but had bitter aftertaste. Texture was very firm (due to underripe?). Maybe, I am sensitive to bitter taste? I don’t like bitter aftertaste in pawpaws.
Too bad that Susquehanna and Overleeese I got were not in a good condition. Taste and texture was quite compromised.
This is not a ripe overleese. I just processed about 10 pounds of overleese yesterday. Not the right color. Overleese is like a very deep yellow. In a good year, I want to say that Overleese is darker yellow (maybe) than Susquehanna. NC-1 always gives me the impression of being even deeper? maybe darker yellow than both.
Also, this looks like it has been sitting in the fridge for a week or two or on the counter for at least a few days post drop. Those darken regions are bruising sometimes indicating cold damage. It can happen on fruit that doesn’t get enough GDD in my experience or early frost. Or from sitting in the fridge, hence my assumption.
2 Likes
I think you are correct.
My guess was it was picked or dropped underripe. Kept in a fridge before it was given to me (the other side of this Overleese was almost all black).
I also was disappointed by my own Mango pawpaws. Flesh near the seeds were almost mushy while the rest was firm, rather odd. It also had bitter aftertaste. It hope it will get better next year. Otherwise, I will graft it over.
Some people say Shenandoah was bland or too mild. I and several of my friends like it. Texture is creamy and smooth. It tastes sweet without bitter aftertaste. That’s good enough for me.
3 Likes
If you consider yourself sensitive, I’m super sensitive. Every Shenandoah I eat I can still pick out a hint of that background bitterness/phenolic aftertaste.
You see that bumpy part of the fruit? Where the skin is uneven? This and the color indicates to me underdeveloped. It was picked too early. Or it fell off too early. This doesn’t happen normally. When this happens the texture is hard and kind of foam like. It will counter ripen, as in get soft, but kind of like the way a green tomato will. Maybe a few streaks of red later, but still won’t ever be the same as a vine ripe.
Even if you don’t thin, and you get a preduncle cluster of like 9 fruit, they will all ripen correctly if given time and have smooth skin. Sometimes you get a calabash gourd shape with fruit (I don’t know why), but even then the skin is smooth and there’s radial symmetry. The bumpy [to me] indicates that it fell off or was picked off early and the air pockets in the less dense fruit were released after cold damage or counter ripening. Hence why it ended up bumpy.
I don’t know what I call the pink thing. But I see that vein sometimes in overripe fruit or fruit that has been counter ripening or in the fridge too long. Every experience I’ve had with it has taught me that it makes you sick.
2 Likes
The Overleese and Susquehanna were from a farm that my friend went to get pawpaws. Somehow, these fruit were picked or dropped underripe.
Look like I have to graft the varieties I want to eat myself.
1 Like
What pawpaws have you had at (that were actually ripe) besides Shenandoah?
Also, this was a weird year for pawpaws in general. Several of the pawpaw orchard owners I talked to mentioned everything falling within two weeks. Definitely not normal.
1 Like
Sunflower, Mango and Wabash.