Stay away from Hirt’s garden

I bought a blackberry and couple of strawberry plants from Hirt’s garden store online and this is what they sent.

The strawberry plants are almost dead with many dead leaves in the box and are so tiny that I thought they were filler boxes.

Please stay away from shady sellers like Hirt’s garden. YMMV but this is the second time I have had a bad experience with them.


Very sad to see that.
It is pretty late in the year to be ordering plants by mail. I will find out how late next week when my latest Hirts order comes in. :roll_eyes:

Long time Hirts customer. 4 orders over the past 2 years. Always thrilled with the hard to find varieties of ornamentals I have purchased from them.
Yes, they sell small plants. But usually healthy and in good condition.
Lol, be warned, they ship as soon as you place an order. I like that because I have places to overwinter stuff till spring. It would be pretty awkward otherwise.
Most of my orders have been hardy evergreens (but grown in a greenhouse and needed hardening off!) shipped in January to March.

Hope your plants bounce back.


It is a good idea to check a nursery’s reviews on Dave’s Garden, a nursery watchdog.

Hirt's Gardens (formerly Hirt's Greenhouse & Flowers).

188 positives, 40 neutrals and 154 negatives. Ordering from it is like playing a Russian Roulette.


Thanks for this tip. I didn’t know about these reviews at all.

Before you buy from nurseries, google Scoop on+ the name of the nursery, Dave’s Garden will show the reviews.

For example. Scoop on Hirt’s Garden

Avoid Ty Ty nursery and its many affiliations. I believe TyTy sued Dave’s Garden and their reviews are not on Dave’s any more but that nursery is very ill reputed. Check out this thread.

1 Like

I bought from hirts before and the plants i received are usually good. I got a Jan and Joel cherry last year and the Jan quickly died. I emailed and they send a replacement Jan and Joel and the Joel quickly died. But again it was very late in the shipping season.

1 Like

When ordering from places new I always like to start here first. Just like you posted a pic others do as well. That gives you a chance to see what it is they sell and hear others chime in with their experience. I would have been disappointed with that order as well.

Doesn’t Hirts tell you the size right there on the page when you are selecting the plant? So you order a 2 inch seedling for $7, and you are disappointed when the 2 inch seedling arrives? If I ordered this blackberry plant in the attached pic below, at that size and price, and it shipped and arrived in livable condition, I would not describe the vendor as “shady”. Hirts is pretty transparent in their sizes and prices.

I have ordered from Hirts a few times and yes the sizes are small, but the prices reflect that. If you are looking for large plants, and are willing to pay a higher price, then skip this vendor.

I sent my mom some hardy kiwi a few weeks ago from a couple different vendors. I ordered her a few plants from Hirts- they were tiny. The price was also tiny. She couldn’t believe how small they were (she mentioned it to me multiple times). I also ordered her some larger sized plants from One Green World. The price was larger. You would have loved the size of the plants from One Green World…but your $7 plant would have been $40 and the shipping would have been more expensive as well.

Flash forward to today- the tiny Hirts plants are doing amazing, and one of the One Green World plants has died. Go figure.

I don’t mind getting small plants. Larger plants are often root bound in a pot.

I’ve also found that Hirts ships immediately- sometimes within a few hours of placing an order. What other vendor ships that fast? I’ve ordered from many different places, and it averages a few days to a few weeks to two months for shipping.


The issue with Hirts is not just they have small plants but the fact they are often mislabeled. 8 dollars for a blackberry is not what I call cheap. Indiana berry has something like 10 dollar shipping to me and has much lower prices. The Apache blackberries there are 4.75 a piece while you are paying 8 dollars. Besides with blackberries you are cutting down the stock to begin with. My raspberry stocks from double a vineyards was already cut for example. With those blackberry stocks OP has I would be worried to cut them.

1 Like

The issue wasn’t the size of the seedlings but the condition which was nearly dead. Did you notice the dead leaves where healthy growth should be? The plants were in extremely poor condition and only the blackberry survived. Even it shed most of the leaves which I don’t mind.

Hirt’s did refund the cost for the strawberry plants that eventually died. This is what I had asked for and Hirt’s was good about that. The fact that they were shipping nearly dead plants as ‘on sale’ items is unethical. Please stop belittling someone else’s experience just because yours wasn’t the same.

1 Like

Honestly looks rather normal to me for its size

1 Like

If you notice the agristarts label in the picture above these are tissue culture plants. There are a few other sellers like wellspring that ship those tiny tc starts as well. I agree it’s fine for the price but always a shock to people who order one of those for the first time! Good thing about tc plants is they are a safe bet to be disease free


I have always had bad luck with tiny starter plants. They never seem to make it through the next winter. To me it is worth it to pay more money for bigger/better ones.


No matter who you buy plants from, if it’s late in the season for bare roots they are not likely to perform that well because they are coming out of dormancy in summer conditions instead of the gentler weather of spring. If they have already begun to leaf out, it is worse, because that means that energy has already been wasted on roots that start to grow and die. It’s like a bank account that has been half drawn on However, such plants usually survive, IME, and you do get a bit of a jump over waiting another year…

If you’d payed full price and gotten them at the ideal time for strawberry plants their small size wouldn’t have mattered much because they grow very quickly when planted at that time.

When you’ve had many seasons of experience with many different nurseries you are in a better position to evaluate them, but Dave’s garden can be helpful. Nowadays many companies don’t invest much in customer service because it is not worth the investment in pure business terms. Small nurseries are often an exception to this, but try getting some help from Google or your health care provider. “Hold please”


I often buy clearance plants for $1 or $2 from the big boxes. And they are nearly dead. I guess one difference there is I can pick the least nearly dead myself while taking advantage of the sale, so I’m seeing what I’m getting. But I don’t consider that unethical.


Not to mention that you are looking at the very bottom of the pile. I have to order my bareroots for early June delivery because that’s the safe bet for Alaska. You should see the crap Stark Bros sent me last year. 2 out of 4 trees died, they just ignored my email asking about their warranty.


I bought many times from hirt’s garden. I think they are very good. Cheap and lots of choice.


i agree that anything shipped from any nursery past mid june is a crapshoot and not likely to survive. i have the same issue as other northern growers so i now preorder over winter and have them deliver in early may and plant out right away so i still get decent stock. ive got s few rare fruits from hirts over the years and had good luck with them but they definitely need some tlc before putting outside. you get what you pay for. you want a well established plant, dont buy from them.


I bought from Hirt’s last year and everything i bought did well.

This year i bought a few more things… as they are very cheap. None of this stuff is sold locally so im going to give them a try.

2 kinds of garlic- Duganski and Nootka Rose - 3 bulbs for $8
Autumn Britten Rasp $6 (these are hard to find)
Ohio Treasure Black Rasp $7 (also kind of hard to find).

I bought some corn seed that ive never heard of… gamble but they are cheap.
$2.69 per pack.

Honey and Cream
Sweet Martian (purple cobs and shucks)!
True Gold

Shipping was $20 for all.


you get what you pay for with them but knock on wood, ive had good luck with them. their plants might need a little tlc but its worth it if you want to save some coin.