Taishu fraud?

Don’t miss the discussion with Harbin above. He says that my “Taishu” isn’t. I have no reason to doubt him. Like some other members of the forum, it looks like I have been a victim of fraud.

My apologies to all those forum members who received scions from me.

Maybe we can figure out what the variety really is. FWIW, it is PCNA, delicious. Lats year was my first decent crop and it appeared to ripen over an extended period lasting a few weeks but beginning somewhat early.

6 Likes

Well, as long as it has good flavor, PCNA, and produces pollen, still would be equally good for persimmon breeding in my opinion.

4 Likes

As I noted in a separate message to @Harbin . . . .

<< I’ve done some further digging. The attached research article published by Japanese breeders shows PICTURES of female, male, and hermaphroditic fruit on Taishu (see Fig 2, p. 46). Also, there is a picture of the fruit displaying the exact same indentation as seen on mine (see Fig. 1B, p. 45). >>

In fact, my (female produced) fruit looks exactly like the one pictured by the Japanese.

I’m not sure where “truth” lies but one thing is clear: The presence of hermaphroditic flowers (and fruit) does not prove that a variety is NOT Taishu. Rather, the presence of such flowers is consistent with reports from Japanese breeders.

JJPS_1242-62.pdf (5.1 MB)

1 Like

I have a ‘Taishu’ graft growing . It hasn’t flowered yet, but here’s what the leaves look like. I got the scion from a local grower, not sure if it’s from the same source as yours. Time will tell.

1 Like