Huh, only $260? I don’t know if there’s enough hype in the entire world to get me jacked enough to spend that much on two trees, no matter who says that they are the most magical best tasting unicorn cotton candy glitter bombs in the entire world. My old boss liked to say that profit is not a dirty word, but I’ve got common sense working on my side.
5 Likes
@krismoriah, if those are trees that you are really interested in growing then I would be willing to chip in for the donation plate to help soften the blow, and I would just ask for some scion wood in the future in return.
2 Likes
I think a couple of folks on here said that they wont grow ‘cheap trees’ so maybe they will buy them. Also several members on some FB groups said that unless a tree costs over $100 its not grafted by an expert.
When Gurney’s comes up with a Gurney’s Exclusive…its usually something that someone else cant sell. They have a fantastic market for folks that arent the most internet savvy.
When is the last time that you saw these for sale?
I-115
C-100
H-118
H-120
I could call Prok ‘Worlds Best Persimmon’ and probably do pretty good with it for a long time. I mean where do u even buy a Prok if u arent a member of some obscure forum? Who even knows what a Prok is on the basic social media groups?
‘Sweet Giant’ blackberry that i just bought from them at $25/plant… is a U of Ark variety that is likely inferior to their others… But that name though… who wouldnt want a sweet giant blackberry?
Who wouldnt want a caramel sugar persimmon? That has no astringency.
3 Likes
got mine at Starks.
2 Likes
Fair point… i only buy the ones when they get cheap with free shipping… the high price tag items i never look at.
Well thats good then. I guess Prok counts as improved. Wasnt it grown from seed from John Gordon and just happened to have larger fruits than others?
2 Likes
So… is ‘Sugar Daddy’ just a male persimmon that they’re grafting and offering as a pollinator (correct term: pollenizer… the insects are the pollinators)? Or is is a polygamodioecious (‘bisexual’), fruiting male, like Szukis or Claypool’s F-100?
No way in lleh that I’d pay $260 for two grafted persimmons, particularly if one is a non-fruiting male that’s going to make the fruit on my female fully seeded.
I also see Gurney’s is claiming ‘bushels of fruit from Aug-Dec’… I don’t know any persimmon that bears ripe fruits over a 5-month period… though I guess if you had folks growing it from zone 8a to zone 5b… the difference in ripening times between a tree growing at Mobile AL - almost to the Gulf of Mexico - and one in northern coastal Maine on the border with New Brunswick might span that timeframe.
4 Likes
We know these are the oldest tricks in the book to get us to buy more and pay more.
2 Likes
P.T. Barnum wasn’t wrong.
I keep telling my wife… the average person is not particularly smart… and at least half the folks out there are below average…
6 Likes
Please don’t get me wrong, I recognize that there is a true cost to bringing something to market, I am just not willing to pay that much for those specific trees.
[Edit] I recognize that with the time that they said they spent to develop these varieties there will also be those additional costs factored in to what they are charging.
1 Like
There are times i pay gurneys price. The carmine jewell was one of those times because i really wanted that cherry a long time. They paid to import it from Canada to the USA. Gurneys pears come from Purdue University. As far as i’m concerned they sell some great things that i’m normally not willing to pay for. If you have a yard that will only accomadate one or two trees spending a few hundred dollars might not seem outrageous. Where i’m from we can lose 30 trees in one storm , it might not be smart to have more than a few dollars in a tree. Will need to graft 30 - 60 trees again from the last two storms that came through. 80 mph + winds can do a lot of damage. If they can snap off a two year old graft that has as much strength as a two x two then what can’t they break? It literally broke off two - three inches thick of pear. The top never was found which would have weighed at least 40 pounds. Literally half a tree is missing! Would you plant those persimmons here?
2 Likes
I doubt that they developed them… likely took them 10 years to convince Jennings to release some of the Claypool varieties.
I think Lehman got a bunch out of Claypools orchards but not all of them.
Big question is are these new ones patented? If so lets say that they patented 100-46… does that mean that folks like Englands that have been selling them for years will be selling a patented variety? or do they become grandfathered?
I know the Praire Series is trademarked…but still sold as their common name.
It will take years to figure out what they really are… then i guess we go from there. You might even have it already?
2 Likes
I always have to remind myself of that while driving… half of the drivers out there are literally below average. 
2 Likes
Has Gurneys made public the background for those varieties?
2 Likes
Everyone grew the unpatentented claypool varities long before anyone tried to trademark some of them. We can grow them but cannot call them a trademarked name. They cannot show up and tell me the 10 persimmons i have grafted are now patented. That genie is out of the bottle.
No they have not told anyone where they came from yet.
3 Likes
Definately know the difference but rarely someone patents a tree that has been available 20 years. They do however trademark it under a different name.
2 Likes
@clarkinks
So were the Claypool trees in question patented or trademarked under different names? As you know, the latter is a whole other ballgame when it comes to scionwood distribution.
1 Like
Gurney’s does not use pest control measures required by a half-dozen U.S. states (varies by species) and yet they charge the same or more than suppliers that do. Consequently if you are in a State that they ship to, you are receiving poorly sanitized plants. Their operation meets the derogatory definition of “cheap”.
1 Like
